Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Physician Assisted Suicide/Mercy Killing

who's talking here?

Vicky 5
Little Miss Knowitall 1
Ja Ja Jacky 1
BOOM BOOM BOOM 2
Kara 2
RMof2 7
Fiction 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Physician Assisted Suicide/Mercy Killing

Two questions: Should there be physician assisted suicde for the elderly or should mercy killings be allowed (to do it cheaper). Is it a sin or not?

Yes it should be allowed and yet it is a sin. (suffer the consequences) Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Yes it should be allowed and no it's not a sin Vote
 
 100.0% (10)
No it should not be allowed...it is a sin Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
No it should not be allowed... and it is not a sin (there are no consequences) Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Vicky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Two questions:
Should there be physician assisted suicde for the elderly or should mercy killings be allowed (to do it cheaper).

Is it a sin or not? 

Fiction --- 13 years ago -

I couldn't care less if it's a sin, as I believe all religion is a sham.

That being said, I also believe it should be allowed. Making someone suffer when they don't want to is selfish, and should a crime in and of itself.

As far as going about it, there should be a mental competency test to make sure the person is of sound mind to make that kind of decision. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

what if they are lucid only part of the time? Quiz them one day, and they are of sound mind. The next day they have the mental capacity of a 2 year old... That's what I am afraid of. Making the decision when I am sound and then when I am not, forgetting the decision.... 

Fiction --- 13 years ago -

what if they are lucid only part of the time? Quiz them one day, and they are of sound mind. The next day they have the mental capacity of a 2 year old... That's what I am afraid of.

This is why you monitor the patient for a while. It's not just a one day decision.

We discussed these kinds of situations at length in my ethics class.
The conclusion a bunch of moral ethics 3rd year philosophy students came to was that there should be a six month period in which the patient is evaluated.

During the six months everything is done to keep the patient at peace and alive. But, also monitoring his or her thoughts on the topic/situation and see if they waiver on their decision.

I know this is ideal for someone on life support, but this would work for someone with a terminal illness just waiting to die. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 13 years ago -

Euthanasia should be able to be part of a person's health care proxy (in a way, it already is - a DNR could be considered a mercy killing). 

Fiction --- 13 years ago -

Euthanasia should be able to be part of a person's health care proxy (in a way, it already is - a DNR could be considered a mercy killing). 



Again +1...

If I know I have only 9 months to live, and I've made my peace with life at 3 months into that time, why make me suffer and wait 6 months every day thinking about death? 

Kara --- 13 years ago -

We give our pets a painful free death when we put them down...why should we make humans suffer? 

Vicky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I agree on all points. Mine is a secular question. Murder is a sin and acting as God (deciding when someone should die) is against the Bible.

Will I go to Hell if I kill myself through physician assisted suicide?

Will my kids go to Hell for holding the pillow over my face or helping me swallow a bunch of pills if my doctor won't help? 

Kara --- 13 years ago -

I will play God Vicky, no they will not. 

RMof2 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I would say that if your doctor refuses (then it would still be against the law to assist) so if you asked your children to help you swallow pills or to hold a pillow over your head then you would be putting them at risk of jail time. I think if the doctor's won't help you then you need to make it a personal decision and not involve someone else. 

RMof2 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

 

Vicky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

RM, I wouldn't ask if it were illegal... I wouldn't ask them to risk anything.

My poll was "should there be and is it a sin" meant that if it were legal and should it be allowed would it be a sin or no?

If it were legal, I could see situations where the doctor and the patient could disagree as well.

Just food for thought. 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

Seriously Kara? 

Fiction --- 13 years ago -

If you believe your God will punish you for not wanting to suffer, then it might be time to start looking for a new God. 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

Oh but God won't give you more than you can handle. Lmao riiiiight! 

RMof2 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Will my kids go to Hell for holding the pillow over my face or helping me swallow a bunch of pills if my doctor won't help? 

How you asked this.. is why I responded the way that I did. If a doctor turned down helping you then I would assume that it were for legal reasons. If it were not for legal reasons you could ask another doctor. I would NEVER ask my children to help me.. despite what I considered a sin or what the law said. I wouldn't have them live with doing that. It's hard enough for people to pull the plug on life support, it would be more traumatic for someone to actually help someone else end their life even if they were suffering. 

RMof2 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

If you believe that you could go to hell for suicide, then why would you risk it with your children "committing murder". I think you have to do what is right for you and what you believe in but you can't make the decision for anyone but yourself. I wouldn't ask anyone but a physician to assist and it wouldn't be the physician administering anything. I would think it would happen by the medical staff setting up the medicine via injection but the person who wanted to die would have to actually press a button for the drug to be administered on there own and that the physician themselves or loved one themselves wouldn't be doing the killing.. That to me is what assisted is. Holding a pillow over someones head.. is murder. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Yes RM... That is what I believe. I was curious how others believe and that's why I made the poll...

Sometimes Christians can justify any action as "allowed" or "not allowed". My children run the spectrum of believing and not believing. (I am not a good Christian but I do try.)

Maybe I am a misinformed Christian. I like to learn. I like to know what others think. I wonder all the time about things and even question my own Christianity on a daily basis.

Thanks for giving me your insight because it helps me to understand more and more.

I am not saying what I believe is right. Nor am I saying it's wrong. It just is.

For the Record, I wish physician assisted suicide was legal. I wish mercy killing was legal for those who could do it (though I could see room for abuse in it). I would not truly want to ask my children to kill me and live with that guilt but like abortion I wouldn't want to take that option away from someone else. 

RMof2 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I don't make any of my decisions based on being a good or bad Christian (I guess that would make me a bad one..) I believe in god, I just don't believe in all of the bs that goes along with being a Christian.

Besides.. if you listen to enough Christians you will realize that they all sin.. They just pick and choose which parts of the bible they want to judge others for while ignoring what they do wrong. I was taught that all sins are equal. Telling a lie, beating your wife, lying with a member of the same sex, murder.. they are all equal. They also can all be forgiven.. Which is why so many Christians will do things "in the name of god" because they know they will be forgiven. These are all things that I just don't get, nor care to really get.. I guess. I care more about the law and if I can look at myself in the mirror. 

RMof2 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I would take that away.. Like I said.. I believe it should have to be the one that died who pushes a button. Otherwise there is just too much risk. There should also be extensive documentation. Could you imagine people killing the loved ones in a rage and saying "they asked me to do it.. it was a mercy killing?".. Nope.. even if they allowed mercy killings, there would need to be documentation showing this is what the person wanted and an evaluation by a medical professional before it could be deemed legal if they did make those things legalized. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Meh. Christians have it easy. Ask for forgiveness and your god forgives you. Yes, you will still go to "heaven". 

RMof2 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Right.. lol

Christians are more afraid of the after life than the life they are in right now. Ever heard of h e double hockey sticks on earth? Pretty sure prison would feel like that. lol. Like I said.. I care more about what the legal system says.. I have no desire to spend my days in prison. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground