Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

11yr old transgender

who's talking here?

Vicky 1
Little Miss Knowitall 1
Ja Ja Jacky 5
Dontchawish 1
Boobsy McNicehiney 3
Double O 7 3
Fulu McVooDoo 1
RMof2 1
Fiction 3
Tarheelover 1
DoUntoOthers 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

 

Fiction --- 13 years ago -

Good for her. She's happy, her family is supportive. Not up to anyone else to judge her... 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I wonder if her parents are going to let her start the estrogen this early or make her wait?

I'd be a sucky mom in this situation because I would be so worried about letting my -child- make life altering decisions at such a young age, like the medication to stop puberty and estrogen etc. but then Id be worried that by not allowing it, my child would miss out. It seems to me that the earlier you stop testosterone, the easier the process is.

I'd be a big ball of nerves. I feel for her parents. But I'm glad that little girl has people beside her that love her unconditionally. 

Fiction --- 13 years ago -

Yeah, not sure how I'd fare in their shoes. Like they said, I'd probably lie to myself and keep calling it a phase. Obviously for this little girl it isn't. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I applaud the parents for standing up for Jazz and trying to make the best decisions for her.

I am not educated in the gay rights arena as much as others might be but I look at transgender differently than being gay so I was confused with the gay rights parade unless it was representing "difference". She is not gay but transgender which is different...(IMHO).

I hope she gets the medical treatment and hormonal therapies that she deserves. 

Boobsy McNicehiney --- 13 years ago -

I didn't have time to watch the video yet.

But, I am all for supporting her to dress as female, but I think having the surgery at such a young age is not wise. Her body is still changing and developing. I feel that way about any elective surgery. Act as female until she is grown, then have the surgery. 

RMof2 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I'd be a sucky mom in this situation because I would be so worried about letting my -child- make life altering decisions at such a young age, like the medication to stop puberty and estrogen etc. but then Id be worried that by not allowing it, my child would miss out.


That's where you would seek family counseling and medical professionals advice on how to go about it. If after weighing out all of the options and having your child evaluated it was the recommendation to start the medication then you would know exactly what to do. It is still an incredibly hard decision to make.. surgery would be absolutely a no go until 18 but I wouldn't even let my underage child get a tattoo that they could regret, sex change surgery is life altering, not just some regrettable ink... so they would have to wait for that. 

Tarheelover --- 13 years ago -

as far as getting any genital surgery she will have to wait until she's over 18,she may be getting breast implants before then I can't remember offhand.
I actually watch the show last week on 20/20 and Jazz is an amazing young lady. 

Double O 7 --- 13 years ago -

Im all for people being happy, but having NO beleif in the whole "I feel like a different gender thing", this whole situation is sickening to me! 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

If you;re all for people being happy, why are you sickened?

The way people feel is the way they feel.


One of my nephews is "different" for lack of a better term. He's 8 years old and has always, from infancy, been feminine. He isn't allowed to be feminine because his dad is very... homophobic. From the time he could walk, which was at about 9 months old, he had always been more interested in barbies, dolls, pink power wheels instead of his blue one, dresses, Dora, care bears, strawberry shortcake. I mean, the list goes on and on. To this day, he gets in trouble regularly because he gets caught playing with barbie doll styling heads and make up.

No one encourages his behavior... actually, it's looked down upon by his own father. He gets punished for it, in the last couple of years. The rest of us can all see that it's just who he is. He's just not ever going to be a manly man. He's always going to be extremely feminine. Don't tell my brother that though because he will punch you (or me) in the face for saying it to him.

Maybe he should have been born a girl. 

Fiction --- 13 years ago -

Im all for people being happy, but

But = ignore everything I said before this..... 

DoUntoOthers --- 13 years ago -

Maybe he should have been born a girl.

I agree. Is it possible nature got it wrong? We all start out as female and then the X gene is needed to become male. Maybe for the people like Jazz, that process got mixed up inside and she really was suppose to be born a female. Who knows. We are living in different times, and I applaud her bravery. 

Boobsy McNicehiney --- 13 years ago -

"I feel like a different gender thing", this whole situation is sickening to me!

You are entitled to your opinion, I just think it's really sad. Not everyone fits into the mold they came in. Nothing wrong with fixing it. I just happen to think 11 is too young, otherwise, I say good for her and good for the parents for not being jerks. 

Dontchawish --- 13 years ago -

Good for her for knowing who she is! I'd personally pick a different name but, that's her choice! 

Fulu McVooDoo --- 13 years ago -

Jazz is a stripper name. Thats all I got. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

That's what I was saying Boobsy. I'm a very strict parent, with the exception of how they express themselves. I don't interfere with my kids clothing/hair/piercing/accessories etc. my rules are it can't be permanent and has to fall within school guidelines. So yeah, I'd definitely struggle with them wanting to act as the other gender. What I'd they change their minds later and resent me for allowing them to make such serious, life changing decisions at such a young age.

Buuuut then again, my kids have always been allowed to express themselves as they see fit so I would have to let them do as they please. But I'd be so worried. 

Boobsy McNicehiney --- 13 years ago -

It's really a tough call. I wouldn't be thrilled, but I'd be supportive. Just wouldn't let the boys cut off their johnson at that age. 

Double O 7 --- 13 years ago -

If you;re all for people being happy, why are you sickened?

The way people feel is the way they feel.


One of my nephews is "different" for lack of a better term. He's 8 years old and has always, from infancy, been feminine. He isn't allowed to be feminine because his dad is very... homophobic. From the time he could walk, which was at about 9 months old, he had always been more interested in barbies, dolls, pink power wheels instead of his blue one, dresses, Dora, care bears, strawberry shortcake. I mean, the list goes on and on. To this day, he gets in trouble regularly because he gets caught playing with barbie doll styling heads and make up.

No one encourages his behavior... actually, it's looked down upon by his own father. He gets punished for it, in the last couple of years. The rest of us can all see that it's just who he is. He's just not ever going to be a manly man. He's always going to be extremely feminine. Don't tell my brother that though because he will punch you (or me) in the face for saying it to him.

Maybe he should have been born a girl.


The situation sickens me because I do not beleive in any of it. Its the way I feel. Sick because the kid has to live this way, sick because of his/her feelings and how he/she will be treated, that its a spectacle on TV etc.

I'm very sorry your nephew lives the way he does and deals with this. The actions drawing so much attention may be the issue...not exactly WHAT he's playing with making him 'different'?

I have a question. Has anyone ever thought or has it been discussed that maybe he is just more in touch with his feminine side? I know straight males that LOVE to plant flowers, help pick out clothes, they are into fashion, home decor etc. But also into building cars, racing, survivalist stuff and doing outdoorsy things... but they are still feminine in other areas.. Does that mean they are 'different' too?

I struggle with this whole situation honestly, I have cousins and friends who are not straight I love them but I do not understand them! 

Double O 7 --- 13 years ago -

Im all for people being happy, but

But = ignore everything I said before this.....


Absolutely not. I wanted to explain WHY before I went into my 'statement' ;) 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

When I used the word different, I didn't use it in place of transgender or gay. I used different because honestly... I don't know how else to define his situation... other than different.

He's not into cars, GI Joes, racing, sports or any other traditional male interests. He'd rather pain fingernails and make flowers out of playdoh and so on.

I don't think he needs to be defined. I don't think his tendencies need to be punished, talked about, encouraged etc. I think he is who he is and everyone should let him be who he is. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 13 years ago -

We all start out as female and then the X gene is needed to become male.

Actually, it's the Y chromosome.

;-) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground