Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

What would you suggest

who's talking here?

~*MarLa Singer*~ 1
Noel 5
champatlife 1
ihateshoes 1
Ja Ja Jacky 1
proud2Busmc 2
His Ashlee 5
L I G 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

His Ashlee --- 15 years ago -

A friend came to me today with what she considers to be a problem. She got pregnant on BC. She has a child who is very ill already so is high needs. She is considering abortion, though I suggested adoption if she absolutely cannot handle another child at this point. I feel torn though. How would you approach the topic again and explain to her there are other options without making her feel attacked? She is very fragile emotionally right now. Am I wrong for suggesting adoption? What advice would you give her? She is asking me, but I don't feel I am the best person for this, seeing as how I don't even have any children yet. 

His Ashlee --- 15 years ago -

That is my problem, I don't believe in abortion either, and they can handle another child financially and everything. I wish she'd reconsider :( 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I dont believe in abortion BUT I think the best thing you can do is tell her you'll be there for her no matter what she decides



^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ yep 

proud2Busmc --- 15 years ago -

is it because she is worried of this child being "ill" too? Because if thats the case they can find out sooner rather then later (my sister has a masters in prenatal genetics so ive heard things before) 

His Ashlee --- 15 years ago -

She is afraid this new baby will not get the attention he or she will need. I brought up amnio and she said that isn't what she was scared of and explained it to me. 

ihateshoes --- 15 years ago -

well that is just silly. There are plenty of people who have ill children and other children and manage it, it sounds like shes just scared of a very unexpected surprise i hope she takes time to think this over its a huge decision and i could never live with myself over either of those options but thats just me 

proud2Busmc --- 15 years ago -

gotya, I can see where her concern is coming from...I've seen it before where one child is ill or developmentally challenged and so the sibling isn't given as much attention or has to act a certain way, but I just couldnt ever imagine the thoughts that would haunt me for the rest of my life wondering what he/she would have been like and if i made the right choice. Thats hard. I agree with everyone else though and no matter my personal beliefs i'd just tell my friend and i am there no matter what 

His Ashlee --- 15 years ago -

That's what I'm trying to avoid MariaMaria, pushing my beliefs onto her. I will be there for her, and I have told her if she does decide to keep the pregnancy I will babysit as often as I can to help out. Her child now goes to a specialist quite often for his treatments so I can see where she is coming from I just don't know how to word these feelings to her and not come across as "uncaring" if that makes any sense. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

That is my problem, I don't believe in abortion either, and they can handle another child financially and everything. I wish she'd reconsider :(

It's not up to you. It's not even up to you to determine whether or not they can handle it, financially. Finances change.

Contrary to popular belief, a friend considering abortion is not something you have the right to offer your opinion on, even when they ask. As you said, she's in a fragile emotional state. That's the only reason she's seeking input on this. All it's going to do in the long run is f*ck her up emotionally when she feels like she's "letting down" a friend or two if she makes the decision to terminate, and it sounds like she already knows that's what's best for her family.

Tell her, because it's the truth, that it doesn't matter what you think, or what anyone else thinks, but what makes HER most comfortable and happy, and that you support any decision she comes to. It's that simple. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

trust that her decision comes from her needs and not yours.

Best comment in this thread. =D 

L I G --- 15 years ago -

I really agree, Noel.

One of my best friends had an abortion and instead of saying to her, "as your friend I support you no matter what you do" I felt it was "my place" to give her my opinion and when she decided to terminate her pregnancy it really hurt me for my own selfish reasons. It put a hole in our friendship that we have yet to fill and I regret it.

I would honestly just let her know you support her no matter what and to remember that she is the one that has to live with the decision for the rest of her life - no one else - just her. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

she is the one that has to live with the decision for the rest of her life - no one else - just her

Exaaactly. I mean, you can offer to babysit as much as you want, you can see that kid daily if you feel like it, but if she has it, SHE has to raise it. Feed it. Nurse it when it's sick. Get up with it in the middle of the night. Discipline it. Dress it. Help it with its homework. Pay for its college tuition. Pay its medical bills. Etc, etc, etc.

If she gave it up for adoption, she'd have to spend her entire life wondering if the people who adopted it weren't really abusers, molesters, scumbags, went broke after adopting, etc. She'd wonder if it would ever find out it was adopted and judge her. She'd wonder if it was even able to be placed in adoptive care.

It is no one's place to try and make a woman feel obligated to put herself through any of that sh*t just because -they- have "moral objections" to the alternative.

I've said it before, I'll say it again, not "believing" in abortion is NOT a good enough reason to take on the responsibility of raising a human being. 

His Ashlee --- 15 years ago -

I agree. It isn't my place, which is why I am so dumbfounded here. I wish she hadn't asked for my opinion because, like stated above, it isn't MY body. It is hers, and it is her life and SHE ALONE will have to live with whatever she chooses to do. I will be there for her no matter what she chooses, but to me, this should be talked between her husband and her. I don't want to be in this position. I have told her this and she went on to tell me I am her best friend and my opinion mattered to her, I wish it didn't with this. I really don't want this decision on my hands. I am not going to be the one to raise the baby or anything else, she is, Bah! I feel like this is personal so I shouldn't have been brought into it. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

You're completely right. I'm sorry you've been put in such an awkward situation. :( Maybe she just relies on you SO much that she doesn't realize when things aren't appropriate, or maybe her mind is completely blown and she doesn't realize how uncomfortable it is for you to be involved in something so intimate.

In any case, best of luck! Hope you're able to navigate this gracefully until everything settles! 

champatlife --- 15 years ago -

Your friend came to probably more for someone to lean on vs a voice of reason, although she asked your opinion. She was either looking for a confirmation of her decission or to be talked out of it. I somehow highly doubt that her decession will be based much on anything you tell her.

So why not be honest, but tell her you will be there for her no matter which path she chooses.

But since the conversation is over with maybe don't even bring it back up unless she asks you again.

This is ultimately her choice as we all know and the only person who I think might get an opinion or try to sway her choice is her husband, though others may disagree, 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Noel, sometimes it's like she lives inside my head and eats my thoughts lol. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

LOL. I miss you. *obligatory heartface that CPU won't allow because it's an HTML gobbling hooker* 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground