Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Panel calls for 3 year freeze on military pay and allowances

who's talking here?

Kaci 2
Vicky 1
Noel 6
Little Miss Knowitall 23
Noted 39
IED 1
Jewel 8
MrsSmitty10 5
:) 5
DaisyMae 1
Ja Ja Jacky 6
Rawr 2
BOOM 10

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Noted --- 16 years ago -

He would be incredibly stupid to go through with this.


Panel calls for 3-year freeze on military pay

By Chuck Vinch - Staff writer
Posted : Thursday Nov 11, 2010 12:48:54 EST

A three-year freeze on basic pay and military housing and food allowances is among 58 recommendations contained in the draft report of President Obama’s National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform that was released Wednesday.

The Debt Commission, as it is informally known, said Regular Military Compensation — basic pay, basic allowance for housing, and basic allowance for subsistence, as well as the tax advantage of those two tax-free allowances — is expected to grow by $9.2 billion from 2011 to 2015.

“A three-year freeze at 2011 levels for these compensation categories would save the federal government $7.6 billion in compensation and tax expenditures,” as well as another $1.6 billion in future retirement pay, for a total of $9.2 billion in savings in 2015. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I mean. I get what you're saying. Sorta. But. Not really.

Why is it a bad idea? Minimum wage doesn't go up every year, so I guess I just see it the same way.

Though, I do think minimum wage should definitely go up more often than it does. And Military pay the same, up more than once a decade, lol. 

MrsSmitty10 --- 16 years ago -

He would be incredibly stupid to go through with this.

agreed. the families who recieve this get it for a reason. they deserve it.

how about cutting pay raises for high officials in washington... bet we could save a buttload of money there too. that'll never happen. 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

how about cutting pay raises for high officials in washington



This is my point, Jacky. Cutting military raises and housing allowances but allowing the politicians to keep their pay is ridiculous. You really can't compare minimum wage working people to the military. It's not the same. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

This is my point, Jacky. Cutting military raises and housing allowances but allowing the politicians to keep their pay is ridiculous.

Agree completely.


You really can't compare minimum wage working people to the military. It's not the same.

The cost of living goes up for EVERYONE. So yes, I can.


It's not really a raise, right? It's an increase in pay to cover the cost of living, or no? The raise comes when they move up a level, right? 

MrsSmitty10 --- 16 years ago -

You really can't compare minimum wage working people to the military. It's not the same.

i was just about to say that. there is too much sacrifice, vulnerability, and risk involved with the military. I feel that the servicemembers deserve the raise. i doubt this will pass.

I spoke to my husband about this and he said DoD does waste a lot of money but there are other areas that could use smarter spending. one idea he had was to issue siff gear to each servicemember for their career instead of each duty station. Save time and money, and they still get their raise each year. 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

The cost of living goes up for EVERYONE. So yes, I can



So you're saying that someone working drive through at McDonalds deserves the same perks as someone who goes to war? I dont understand that.

The COLA is only for housing. They are also cutting annual military pay raises. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

They are also cutting annual military pay raises.


Ooooooh. Okay. =) 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

So you're saying that someone working drive through at McDonalds deserves the same perks as someone who goes to war?


No. I am saying, if it was a cost of living increase... then I don't see why it NEEDS to go up every year with our country in a financial bind.


I feel that way for ALL government jobs. We NEED to lower our deficit. Cutting school funding... is getting old. If we didn't hand out a yearly raise to all government employees for just one year, it would surely help A LOT. 

Kaci --- 16 years ago -

But yet in obamas campaign he was all about "raising" military wages :(( 

Kaci --- 16 years ago -

how about cutting pay raises for high officials in washington... bet we could save a buttload of money there too. that'll never happen. 

Completely agree!! 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

If we didn't hand out a yearly raise to all government employees for just one year, it would surely help A LOT.


I understand that but my question is, if they cut all civilian raises for one year, would you be okay with that?

Cut one, Cut all.

They can't keep a fighting force in American without offering specific perks. Raises, college, housing, pay, insurance- those perks go away and who will fight for America? No one.


I would be willing to take a pay freeze on the raise for ONE year as long as every government employee got the same. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I understand that but my question is, if they cut all civilian raises for one year, would you be okay with that?


Yep. I'm saying, if we need it. And we do. Then do it. For all of America. I guess I was just using a bad example up there. 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

I guess my question was really, if it were your pay getting cut would you be okay with that?

I agree, I'm just playing devils advocate here. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I guess my question was really, if it were your pay getting cut would you be okay with that?


Well, cut. No. But not getting a raise... if it were going to benefit the future of our country (that future being my kids) then yes. No raises for a year!

I'm so tired of seeing school budgets cut. This country needs some serious fixing. And it needs to start at the top... 

IED --- 16 years ago -

Minimum wage and basic pay don't need to go up, so long as there is nothing to adjust for. Have you ever noticed that when BAH rates go up, so goes the price of rent? I've seen it happen. Inflation is a big B, but so is the system of taking advantage of a situation like that. If people are paid more, the market finds a way to get more of that cash out of their pockets. The way to control that is if more people are aware of rising prices, and refuse to buy things because of that. If the demand goes down, the supply rises, and prices have to drop and the .manufacturers adjust accordingly. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

I guess my question was really, if it were your pay getting cut would you be okay with that?

I'd rather get a pay cut/freeze than to not have a job at all. 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

For those who want to sign the petition that's going to Harry Reid-

http://www.gopetition.com/petition/40609/signatures.html 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

• one recommendation calls for adjusting Tricare enrollment fees, co-pays and deductibles, an idea that the Pentagon has proposed - unsuccessfully - for three years running as a way to address its soaring medical budget.

• The new Debt Commission recommendation would raise premiums and co-pays by smaller, unspecified amounts and would squeeze most of its cost savings from a new requirement that private-sector employers reimburse the government for the employer share of health care costs for working-age retirees who use Tricare instead of their employer-provided health plan.

• The commission also recommends shutting down the military's stateside school system

• Reduce military personnel stationed at overseas bases in Europe and Asia by one-third.

• Cut spending on facilities maintenance.

• Apply the $100 billion in overhead savings that Defense Secretary Robert Gates wants to squeeze out of the defense budget to deficit reduction, rather than reinvesting it in force structure and weapons modernization, as Gates would like to do.

• Freeze federal salaries, bonuses, and other compensation for the DoD civilian workforce for three years.

• Double the number of defense contractor positions scheduled for elimination from 10 percent of current staff augmentees to 20 percent.

• Reduce procurement by 15 percent, or $20 billion.

• Eliminate the V-22 Osprey program, the Marine Corps' Expeditionary Fighting Vehicle program, the Navy's Future Maritime Prepositioning Force, new Joint Light Tactical Vehicle, the Ground Combat Vehicle, and the Joint Tactical Radio.

• Cut the planned number of F-35 Joint Strike Fighters in favor of more F-16s and F/A-18Es.

• Cancel the Marine Corps' F-35 program. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

Cut the planned number of F-35 Joint Strike Fighters in favor of more F-16s and F/A-18Es.

• Cancel the Marine Corps' F-35 program.


With those two items, sounds like we're in for another round of BRAC. 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

• Double the number of defense contractor positions scheduled for elimination from 10 percent of current staff augmentees to 20 percent.

^^ 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

You really can't compare minimum wage working people to the military. It's not the same.

i was just about to say that. there is too much sacrifice, vulnerability, and risk involved with the military. I feel that the servicemembers deserve the raise. i doubt this will pass.



The flaw in that way of thinking is that it's only a percentage of military members who even do deployments, and only a percentage of -those- who deploy to war zones.

Plenty of enlistees will never see Iraq, Afghanistan, or any other situation more dangerous than driving to work to their desks, where they will sit all day, every day until they retire. They don't "fight" for freedom, they are simply signed into a contract saying they would if forced, and plenty only join so they'll GET these benefits. Why is that more deserving than what I do, or what Deb does, or Jacky's husband, of a consistent pay raise?

Not every job in the military is dangerous, period. Yes, they could be all at once called on to act in a manner that is life threatening, but they aren't. There are many military members who are in no more danger than civilians.

Meanwhile, the military is far from the only dangerous job, and far from the only dangerous job that matters in this country.

Lobby for pay raises for construction workers - they're the reason you have a home, and your husband a building to work in, yet I know some people consider that a "cushy" job because it already pays well. It friggin' should! Or the kids who stock your groceries - no glamor, no glory, certainly no thanks, but they put food on the shelves so you can put it on the table. Etc, etc, etc.

I don't mean to demean the importance of many military members, but it drives me crazy when they're singled out in this way, when the military is blanketed as -nothing- but noble sacrifice deserving of all sorts of honors and benefits, when some of it is just schlub work like the "rest of us."

/rant.

*edited to remove all-caps words* It always seems like a good idea until I re-read the post. Then it just looks like I'm shouting. And it came out snarkier than I meant it. 

:) --- 16 years ago -

yes we have marines that are desk jockeys but their job is important yeah it may not be fighting off terrorist but that doesn't mean their job is not as equally as important.
It doesn't mean they do not go off to Iraq or Afghanistan. Many times they are the ones that will go for a year or longer and is that not a sacrifice? so if they never are to go off to war or see war then they are very lucky.Its like saying my husband who works on planes while here at CP and on deployment is in little danger becuase he is not out in the action doing convoys and busting down doors he is not sacrificing or has a dangerous job.
Like I have heard Every Marine is a rifleman. not matter if you are a desk man or out on EOD.
sorry I will get off my soap box now....I truly think that congress should take more then a year payfreeze but we all know thats not likely to happen.
sorry im not trying to be snarky either.... 

:) --- 16 years ago -

I think alot of people deserve pay raises. I am really tired of the whole change crap that Obama thinks he is going to do... has anything he has done helped at all .....NOPE! time to think of something else to try 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

yes we have marines that are desk jockeys but their job is important yeah it may not be fighting off terrorist but that doesn't mean their job is not as equally as important.
It doesn't mean they do not go off to Iraq or Afghanistan.


Okay, straight away you've missed the point.

If you're talking about people in the military who deploy to those places, you are not talking about the same people that I am.

I cannot make it clear enough - plenty of military members will never deploy there. Those who will never deploy, or will never deploy to dangerous locations, are who I was talking about.

And I didn't say their jobs weren't important, I said they aren't dangerous or sacrificial.

Its like saying my husband who works on planes while here at CP and on deployment is in little danger becuase he is not out in the action doing convoys and busting down doors he is not sacrificing or has a dangerous job.

No, it's not. Not even close. It's saying that some enlisted members are never placed in danger or deployed to war zones. So . . . your aircraft mechanic husband who deploys is included. . . how?

What you just said there makes a point for me, in fact. My problem with the concept expressed, here, is that it only focuses on the sacrifices made by military members.

My point is that some do NOT sacrifice any more than a civilian, and that some civilians sacrifice more than enlistees. Therefore, every single military member, generally speaking, is not more deserving of anything than every single civilian.

No one actually said that they were, explicitly, but that's the taste that's left in my mouth when people focus exclusively on the military deserving raises "because they're in danger and sacrificing." 

BOOM --- 16 years ago -

The cost of living goes up for EVERYONE. So yes, I can.


True, but if you work for any company or business, especially one that puts your life on the line, you would expect a pay raise or a bonus at the end of the year. This is two totally different things. Pay raises and minimum wage. I would expect my employer to give me a raise of some sort every year. If not, then why the hell am I still working for them? 

:) --- 16 years ago -

My point is that some do NOT sacrifice any more than a civilian, and that some civilians sacrifice more than enlistees. Therefore, every single military member, generally speaking, is not more deserving of anything than every single civilian.
I agree with you ...how many contractors go over to foreign countries to help rebuild becuase the military is needed other places. Also alot of civilans get paid much more then most military members, thats not saying that military members are given free medical care, which seems to be one of the last privilages so to speak that the military has.
I am not saying that we bow to all military members and that they are the only ones deserving of raises, I know my mom is going to suffer from this federal freeze if it in fact goes into act. So I guess it could be said that not just military member but civilans will suffer. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

I'm going to post this and once again be labeld "anti-military", but here goes.

Everyone in today's military CHOSE to be there. It was a career CHOICE someone made, just as someone decides to be a school teacher, cook or candlestick maker.

The person deciding to join the military KNEW the risks going in, just as a police officer or fireman know the risks of their occupation.

No one is guaranteed a pay raise in ANY job.

The military should be no different.

Private sector companies give raises when they can AFFORD to. The government shouldn't be any different.

The military is WELL compensated for their service.

Take your spouses current base pay, add in BAH, BAS and any other benefits (health insurance, etc.) and compare it to occupations in the private sector.

As far as being in a war zone, service members are ADDITIONALLY compensated for putting themselves in harms way.

After the initial contract is over, service members are given a bonus for re-enlisting.

Private sector can do away with your job with little or no notice. There is no separation pay when you've done your time. If you're very lucky, the company may give you a few month's severence pay if they're laying you off and you've been with the company a long time. Otherwise, you get to sign up for unemployment and receive 1/2 salary until you find something else or your benefits run out.

Very few private sector companies have retirement plans, so after you've done your time, good luck living on social security, unless you were able to sock away some money in an IRA account. 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

Exactly my point. Everything - and I mean everything on the entire planet - is specific to the people involved. You absolutely cannot say, "That person is in the military, therefore he is noble, just and good, and will spend his life fighting the front lines for our freedom." He may be a bum, or a womanizer, he may have chosen the service to avoid prison, like my brother.

Just as you cannot say, "That person works in a call center, therefore she is lazy and has no real skills, and will never do anything to make this world a better place." She may spend her weekends volunteering at a battered women's shelter, or have once been a police officer who wrestled crackheads to the ground, etc, etc, etc.

You just can't assume that one group of people deserves or doesn't deserve anything based on job title. 

:) --- 16 years ago -

this is one thing I don't get.... everyone complains at one time or another about pay, not getting a raise, etc, but get this overwelming feeling that miltary is not allowed to complain about not getting a raise becuase we are given BAH and BAS along with other privilages. You are right about military member chosing to join, just like any civilan chooses the job that they may be currently working.As of right now many are lucky to re enlist and as for a bonus unless you are doing something highly dangerous you will pretty much be getting a pat on the back for re enlisting. AS well as many civilans are lucky to have the jobs that they have if it is a CEO of a company to working as a Janitor at a high school or fast food.
SO what about military's shift pay or what about overtime? how about some time and a half Or holidays off? What about FMLA? What about sick days? 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground