Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

This is horrible

who's talking here?

~*MarLa Singer*~ 4
Little Miss Knowitall 2
Muse 11
IED 2
countrygrl 1
Doctor of Veterinary Medicine 5
Cricket 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Muse --- 16 years ago -

More reason to become vegan.....


The stress of living in extremely cramped cages often causes egg-laying hens to become aggressive. To prevent them from pecking each other to death, their beaks are routinely sheared off without anesthetic. Evidence exists that this painful procedure leaves the birds in pain for the rest of their short lives.


• Almost all dairy cows are confined to stalls for most of their lives; in a dairy factory, a cow typically lives about four years, far less than its natural lifespan of around 20 years.


• Veal calves are taken from their mothers shortly after birth. They are fed a special formula that deprives them of iron. This causes anemia and diarrhea that leaves the calves weak and sick throughout their lives, but this makes their flesh tender and pale.


• Most female pigs in factory farms spend much of their lives in stalls so small they cannot turn around, a stressful confinement that often cripples their hooves and legs.


• The stress of close confinement in small cages can cause cannibalism in male pigs.


•Transportation to slaughterhouses often occurs under painful and brutal conditions, as does the slaughter itself. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

This makes me want to go back to being a vegetarian. 

Doctor of Veterinary Medicine --- 16 years ago -

*about to explode!!!!*

Okay... I don't think I have enough time in the day to dispute this.

Bird beaks are NOT sheared off. When they are literally 1 day old, the chicks/poults (baby birds) are "processed". They are sexed, vaccinated, & yes, their beaks are trimmed. But, they are not sheared. Their heads are put into a 'cup' of sorts & an infrared light flashes that deadens their beak. Over the next several days, the very tip of the beak will slough off. It's SUPER SUPER SUPER quick (less than a second) & "painless".

Cage layers are in small cages; yes. But, they are typically housed with only 3 other birds. They will live w/ the same group for their life (not very long, granted) but they typically don't peck @ each other. Each bird is provided with it's on feed line & water source. The birds are also only 3 pounds; so the space requirements might be cramped for your typical, average, outdoor chicken (but not for a 3# bird).

Not all dairy cows are housed in stalls! In fact, most have access to pasture or some sort of dry lot for the day & are then brought in for milking 2-3x per day. Lifespan is very dependent on reproductivity -- as long as she's getting pregnant, producing a calf, & producing milk, she'll stay. Average lifespan is typically 6-8 years. I don't think a cow lives 20 years.

Veal calves are taken away from their mothers; so are all dairy calves. They are not fed a feed source that is deficient in anything -- they are bottle fed MILK. What makes their meat so tender is the fact that they're only fed milk (lifespan is VERY short) & are kept in small-ish pens to prevent muscle "hardening" (for lack of a better word; maybe development is bette? It's really to prevent their muscles from being "overused" which leads to tougher meat.)

Yes, female pigs are kept in GESTATION CRATES. No, they aren't able to turn around in these crates. They aren't kept in these crates their entire life -- just throughout their pregnancy (which is 3 months, 3 weeks, & 3 days long). It is not the stress of confinement that leads to leg & hoof issues -- it's the concrete slab flooring. But, the slab flooring is necessary for sanitation.

Males are not kept in close confinement STALLS. They are group housed in pens. What causes "cannibalism" is CURIOUSITY.

Transportation is tricky. But there are rules & regulations on how it's done.

I won't touch slaughter. I know it's a tough subject & hard to swallow. If you're curious... PM me or ask -- then I'll discuss it.

I am all for a discussion on animal welfare & animal production. I will GLADLY talk about it & I would love to dispell some of the myths that are out there.  

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

YAY! Thanks DVM for dispelling some of the myths. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

DVM did you live on a farm? 

Doctor of Veterinary Medicine --- 16 years ago -

YAY! Thanks DVM for dispelling some of the myths.

Ha, welcome! I could do this all day. I love being able to shed some light on animal production & welfare & I LOVE bustin' myths about it.



DVM did you live on a farm?

No ma'am. I'm in veterinary school. We talk EXTENSIVELY on animal welfare & animal production. 

countrygrl --- 16 years ago -

Every dairy farm I've ever driven by has tons of cows out in a HUGE FIELD. None of these "allegations" will make me become vegan 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

I'm in veterinary school

Yea it's kind of hard to miss that lol I did not know that DVMs talked about this stuff, good to know.

Although it seems a bit more "humane" I still feel bad for these animals. I watched "how it's made" last week, and they showed dairy cows in stalls that basically lived in luxury where they chose when they were milked and so forth. Is that true for most dairy cows or just ones in high end farms? 

Cricket --- 16 years ago -

maybe my uncle's dairy farm is an exception but those are some very spoiled, well looked after cows...lol! They ALL get bathed regularly... have both pasture and stall access at all times (unless weather is bad)My uncle almost froze himself to death one winter trying to track down ONE of his missing cows... he has several hundred...
They know when it's time to be milked too... it's funny! They line up outside the big barn mooing to get in... once inside, they all "take their spot" - get cleaned and hooked up to machines and all the while munching away on some feed... they do this ALL by themselves (save for the milkers hooking up) when they're done, they wander back out to pastures or to another barn that has stalls - not a bad life for a cow ;) 

Doctor of Veterinary Medicine --- 16 years ago -

Yea it's kind of hard to miss that lol I did not know that DVMs talked about this stuff, good to know.

Although it seems a bit more "humane" I still feel bad for these animals. I watched "how it's made" last week, and they showed dairy cows in stalls that basically lived in luxury where they chose when they were milked and so forth. Is that true for most dairy cows or just ones in high end farms?


Haha! Sorry about the Captain Obvious comment on being in vet school. :-] We do! I really appreciate it, too -- because things like this are what our clients hear about & want to talk about, etc.

I must admit, some of it is hard to swallow. Especially if you weren't raised on a farm or have a soft spot for animals. Not all farms are cushy & fantastic as you've described. Most farms are kept really clean & the cows are well taken care of. Afterall, they NEED to be if you want them to produce calves & milk. On the other end of the spectrum, there are farms that are below standard & live in horrible conditions.

The way dairy cows (& other production animals, too) are housed is very dependent on environment, geographical location, season, "conditions", etc. For example, if it's literally a frozen tundra outside, those dairy cows will be kept indoors. If it's too hot, probably kept indoors. If it's beautiful outside, they'll probably be outside -- whether they have pasture depends on if the grass has come in, if they've had enough rain, how many cows, the amount of land, etc.

Another myth is organic -- organic starts @ day 1... meaning that antibiotics or vaccines or insecticides or whatever can be used @ any time PRIOR to day 1!!! 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

have a soft spot for animals.

Yep I always wanted to be a vet when I was young, until I learned that I'd have to put animals "to sleep" or see them die. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

*Whoa, killers.


It was information that was undisputed from an Ethics class. I didn't do any personal research on it and was only posting it because it IS sickening.

Secondly, while I'm glad you were able to counter-attack (yes, that's what I saw LOL!!), I'm sure there are some unscrupulous places where stuff like this does occur so therefore, I would have no idea if the meat I'm eating came from them or from a reliable source of meat.

And countrygirl- obviously, I would never become a vegan based off of information I didn't research- I was just saying that those reasons are MORE reason to become vegan.


Geeeeez. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Also, upon further research, I have found some sites that appear to be credible. I can't dispell their claims because I don't have the time at present but just for reading purposes, I'll post them. There are whole movements based off of these "allegations" and I don't understand why they would have movements if none of these allegations were accurate:

Directly addresses the claim that some animals are deliberately fed a liquid diet low in iron

addresses that male pigs turn to cannibalism when used in factory farming

Addresses the life expectancy of cows in factory farming.. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Also, PETA has information on the low iron stuff, too.


PETA 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

MN,

here's a topic you might suggest to your professor...

The disemination of information without fact checking - ethical or not?

I mean this sincerely and it is in no way meant to attack you.

I think it would be a very good topic for discussion in an ethics class.

This type of thing is done all the time, along all lines of communication. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

It wasn't used for a discussion. We were using it in conjunction with other information in a case study. And if you DO fact checking, you can see that this stuff DOES happen- maybe it's not "the norm" but it does still happen. 

IED --- 16 years ago -

I never really think about the welfare of the animals that I eat. Maybe that is sad, but it is the way of the world. I think that many people have MUCH more important things to worry about than how the animals may or may not be treated. I would worry much more about things like proper sanitation procedures followed when the animals are processed into food. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Also, here is this:

Products fed for veal production
contain a relatively low concentration
of iron to attempt to provide enough iron to
avoid anemia but not enough to affect meat
color adversely at slaughter. Concentration may
be up to 40 ppm iron for the first 2 mo but
commonly only 10 to 15 ppm iron for the veal
finishing period. National Research Council
(10) recommendation for iron supplementation
of milk replacers fed to herd replacements or
dairy beef is 100 ppm DM with an upper limit
of 1000 ppm.

Written by these doctors:

K. J. JENKINS and M. HIDIROGLOU
Animal Research Centre ~
Research Branch
Agriculture Canada
Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0C6


Link 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

would worry much more about things like proper sanitation procedures followed when the animals are processed into food.




Which isn't really a problem if you're a vegan :p 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Another article which states:

Bob veal, from young dairy-type calves, is used primarily for processed meat. Special-fed veal calves (also referred to as formula-fed, fancy, or nature veal) usually are fed a milk-based liquid replacer diet in which the iron content decreases through the last half of the production cycle. This relatively low dietary iron concentration helps to retain the lighter muscle color that is considered typical for special-fed veal. Special-fed calves are raised in enclosed housing for 18-20 weeks


and that comes from:

Richard G. Warner
Animal Science Department
Room 118 Morrison Hall
Cornell University
Ithaca, New York 14853-4801



Link 

IED --- 16 years ago -

Which isn't really a problem if you're a vegan :p

_________________________________

You say that now, but then you get a big problem like the E.Coli in spinach problem we had just a year or two ago and the same thing applies. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

E Coli can definitely come from spinach but it also comes from a lot of other things (i.e. meat, a flooded toilet, etc).


I'm not vegan. I dont pretend to be. I typically live by the Utilitarian concept- ask what the long term consequences are for any and all individuals (human and animal) that are to be taken into consideration when calculating consequences.


The end justifies the mean. You can't put farmers out of work because ultimately, humans are superior. Putting a human out of work negatively affects humans and their human families. 

Doctor of Veterinary Medicine --- 16 years ago -

MN -- I didn't mean my post to come off as an attack; which it did. :-/ & I didn't assume that you had come up w/ these facts based on your research. I assumed they were facts you found from another source, etc that you were sharing. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Eh, it's cool! I e-know how you are so I took no offense :)

I was just pointing out that there IS some research to corroborate the allegations after all. :)

It's still sickening to me and I also have OCD when it comes to food. I'm not a huge meat eater in general but I confess, I haven't had a chicken nugget since I watched Jamie Oliver's food revolution! 

Doctor of Veterinary Medicine --- 16 years ago -

Have you seen Food, Inc?

I went to a turkey processing plant (Butterball) on Friday. It was... interesting. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I haven't. I don't know if I COULD! I"m SUPER ocd on food. Although, I'm fat so maybe I SHOULD see all the unhealthy way foods are made....LOL! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground