Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Some Guidance on "Don't Ask - Don't Tell"

who's talking here?

SugarCanesOldProfile 2
~*MarLa Singer*~ 4
Bishany 5
Vicky 3
Noel 10
Muse 1
champatlife 5
Passion Parties by Sarah 1
Karnagia-a 1
mommy of 2 1
Kelsi 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Vicky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Received in an email this morning: Subject: Guidance for Marines re: Don't Ask Don't Tell The following guidance has been provided by higher headquarters for all military personnel: Following the President's State of the Union speech Jan 27, the topic of Don't Ask, Don't Tell (DADT) reemerged as an item of discussion. Media have been looking for service members to comment for "What the Marines/Sailors/Soldiers/Airmen really think of DADT" stories. Note: Our policies have changed many times over the years. In the 1940's a new policy allowed women to serve in the military. Also in the 1940's a new policy began the desegregation of the military. In 1993, a new policy allowed homosexuals to serve in the military. The policy being debated now would just allow them to serve openly -- however, at this time, the policy remains unchanged until a decision is made. Guidance for Marines and Sailors: 1.) You are entitled to your opinion and if you choose to share it in a public venue then you are responsible for what you say. Ensure your comments are not disrespectful of your commanders, of DoD, of the USMC, or of our elected officials (President, Congress). 2.) Don't speculate. A common reporter device is, "What if?" If you are asked to speculate i.e. "Will allowing gays to serve openly adversely/positively affect the military?" An appropriate response is: "Since no policy change has been implemented, I can't speculate on how it would affect the military one way or another." 3.) Don't "out" anyone. Don't identify case examples. 4.) Avoid vulgar words/descriptions for "homosexuals". If you want to share your opinion, an appropriate response is: "This is how I feel ... BUT, how I feel about a policy has no bearing on my ability to adhere to it." If you don't want to share your opinion, an appropriate response is: "It would not be appropriate to comment on presidential / congressional discussions." 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

"It would not be appropriate to comment on presidential / congressional discussions." 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

:o/ It's like the whole world needs to grow up. 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

I'm just curious where the guys showing each other their balls comes into play. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

I'm just curious where the guys showing each other their balls comes into play. LOLOL 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

LOLOL D was on the flightline, and someone ran out and said "your wife called the shop it's an emergency." so he ran in and grabbed his phone there was a text and it was a picture of a guy from his shop's balls. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

Haha ewww 

Vicky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I say the guidance is a good thing...A Marine Corps Order wasn't issued to silence Marines and Sailors which shows growth.... And my point of view (in case you want to know) is "Fine, serve openly but not flamingly and serve with pride and respect. Don't use your sexual preference as a reason to expect preferenctial* treatment." I am sure that most of the men and women in the military know who is who now without issue. Don't make the repeal of the DADT into one. *and the star is because I don't feel like looking up how to spell the word... 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

"Fine, serve openly but not flamingly and serve with pride and respect. Don't use your sexual preference as a reason to I'm just thinking that some guys might start wearing a bra and stuffing it in uniform. (i know it's extreme) but I don't think there is any problem with the policy that needs to be fixed. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

I get what you are saying Vicky, it's just sad that grown adults need guidance on how to treat their peers. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Yes, it is sad that some adults need guidance on how to treat others with respect and it is also unfortuante that the President cannot issue guidance to the general public, but the Marine Corps is "required to".... I don't think that the majority of Marines NEED the guidance, but I can see where the media can take a man or woman in uniform and skew what they say in the news....(and they don't have to actually be in uniform...just being married to active duty sometimes places an unfair spotlight on spouses)... 

Passion Parties by Sarah --- 16 years ago -

While I was in a decade ago, I knew a few gay men in my unit and never had a problem with it and they never broadcasted it, which is how I think ppl should be at work. Business and pleasure never mix well, so whatcha do after work is ur business, not everyone elses. After gettin out I found out that my CO was gay. It was a shocker but then it made it clear why this Richard Gere look-a-like wasn't married. More power to him and it goes to show, ur sexual preference does NOT affect how u do ur job. 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

It was a shocker but then it made it clear why this Richard Gere look-a-like wasn't married. More power to him and it goes to show, ur sexual preference does NOT affect how u do ur job. I had a teacher, and after i graduated I was at my exes bar (owner was gay) and upstairs they had leather club meetings and he showed up dressed to impress that night) 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

I'm just thinking that some guys might start wearing a bra and stuffing it in uniform. (i know it's extreme) but I don't think there is any problem with the policy that needs to be fixed. Ain't that just some straight-up stereotyping bologna. The majority of gay people do not act this way. In fact, I currently live in the gay capital of the country. You see 'em. I know 'em. They are regular human beings going about their regular lives. The problem with this policy that needs to be fixed? Its smack-you-in-the-face unfairness. A straight service member can come to work and talk about his wife. Don't believe me? Visit ANY military shop in the country - I've done it, my family has all served - that's what happens. People talk to their coworkers about their family lives, even in the military. Gay people, because they aren't allowed to be openly gay, can't say, "Yeah, me and my boyfriend went ___ and ____" without risking getting in trouble. It's -crap.- I'm so happy this stupid, useless, cruel, unfair policy is coming under fire again! Yay! 

Kelsi --- 16 years ago -

How would people react in the workplace if sexuality was allowed to be flaunted? Would the higher ups feel the need to seperate, such as on ships? What would be the rule regarding marriage in the military, and families? I personally think they should be allowed to be open, just not in the workplace. And they shouldn't be punished for their orientation... But baby steps... I'm not sure everyone is ready for a complete 180 on this policy. Lots of details to work out. 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

Sadly, Kelsi, until religion has no more hold on politics, gays will not be allowed to marry everywhere, the military won't have any bearing on state law about that. And, sex ITSELF is NEVER allowed to be "flaunted" in the work place, whether you're straight or gay. That can be considered harassment, or make people uncomfortable, and can get you in trouble. THAT rule doesn't need changing. But being allowed to join in a casual conversation about your home life, the person you spend your life with? That's not flaunting your sexuality. There is no reason - well, no reason that a sane person could defend - why that shouldn't be allowed to gays. 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

I personally think they should be allowed to be open, just not in the workplace. Then you also believe a straight person is not allowed to be open in the work place, naturally. That you should never, ever know a person's orientation, that a man can never say "wife," that a woman can never say "husband?" 

Kelsi --- 16 years ago -

I do agree, I'm just thinking out loud. This policy should change, in baby steps is all. 

Kelsi --- 16 years ago -

Okay let me straighten out what I mean: sex should not be discussed in the workplace. If a gay guy wants to talk about where him and his boyfriend alan went on vacation, I don't see a problem. 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

Yeah, I totally agree with that. I hated when the guys on the showroom floor would brag about their sexual escapades at work. Yuck. I just don't agree with the baby steps method. I think people have been allowed to tip-toe around this for too long, and the result is that equal rights are being "postponed." They should simply be had, enjoyed. Not applied for and waited on, you know? 

Kelsi --- 16 years ago -

I'm just worried about the sort of negative reaction that would make politics change it back, that's why I say baby steps. Because of religion, I think people will see this equalization in a different light (not the same as women and race). I'm not that thickheaded, but you know some people are. 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

Blugh, do I ever. There will, most definitely, be a negative reaction, there's no doubt about it. Anytime a freedom is given that a certain type of person doesn't agree with, even if it doesn't HURT them, they go on the offensive. I suppose this is just my naive hope that, if the -military- steps up and says to those people, "Shut up, you no longer get to dictate how other people live their lives based on YOUR personal moral code," it could become a trend. And then we'd have a much better country, one I could truly be proud of! 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I'm going to give my opinion and then gracefully bow out of further debating. I don't agree that people are born with homosexual/bisexual traits- I believe it's a choice. I believe what the bible says regarding laying with the same sex. However, I don't care if they get married. I don't agree with it but I don't really CARE if they do because it's their life and that decision doesn't negatively impact me, my family or society as a whole. That being said, I don't agree with repealing the DADT policy. I think that it's fine the way it is with the exception that gays are kicked out if they say that they are gay. I guess what I mean is, If you're gay and want to serve your country then so be it. You should be able to do so. However, I also feel that alot of emphasis on "gays are allowed in the military now" headlines will only boost enlistment numbers for the wrong reason. I feel some may join specifically because they can and then they won't be able to hack it in the military (some, not all). I also feel as if it will be a huge adjustment to infantry units and could lead to more hazing. I think that some not so honest people could even ruin the careers of current military member's by crying "sexual harassment" if a dirty joke is told. There could be reprecussions where the gay person is unfairly accused as well. Simply put- I don't believe it will be a good thing. 

mommy of 2 --- 16 years ago -

im so happy this topic came up...my bf works in a shop and one of the guys is gay and is like always tryin to touch his shoulder and makes gay comments to him he tells him to knock it off but he dont really wanna scream at him n flip out is there any way that he can be nice to him and hopefully he will stop bc bf cant take it anymore but he wants to be nice about it and tell him he needs to stop but dont wanna say it in front of everyone i guess he dont want to put his biz out there. does anyone know what he can do about this? 

Bishany --- 16 years ago -

I know I am going to ruffle alot of peoples feathers.. But... I believe that there shouldn't be any revisions to this law. I do not think that everyone is ready for it. My husband and I are both from the south (not saying everyone from the south is like this) But we don't agree with the lifestyle as most don't down there. I know my husband would be creeped out if he had an openly gay man on a boat with him for 6 months in the same place they sleep. Women aren't allowed on the ships with them so I don't see why gay men should be either. 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

I know my husband would be creeped out if he had an openly gay man on a boat with him for 6 months in the same place they sleep. Women aren't allowed on the ships with them so I don't see why gay men should be either. That's your husband's personal prejudice that he needs to deal with. So much of the argument FOR this policy is based on absolutely -stunning- misconceptions about gay people. Gay men are just like straight men. SOME of them are lecherous perverts. Just like straight men. MOST of them probably wouldn't even find your husband attractive. The idea that all gay men are going to harass and abuse straight men is really wearing thin on me, they're not some sub-species of human called "EverHorny." Mommyof2, what your husband is experiencing, if he's telling the truth, is sexual harassment. He needs to speak with his superior about it, PERIOD. It doesn't matter if a gay man or a straight woman is touching him. If he's uncomfortable and he has tried to make him stop, then he (your husband) needs to follow the rules and make a formal complaint. Maria, you and I obviously won't see eye to eye on this, which is fine, but if homosexuality was a choice, it wouldn't be found in the animal kingdom, where they only act on instinct. The situation you describe if gays are allowed to serve openly happens right now with straight people. ALL human beings have the capacity to behave badly. That's why the military has so many conduct rules. Refusing gay people the right to say, "Yeah, my boyfriend/girlfriend bought me flowers this weekend, it was sweet!" won't bring about anything you're afraid of. The small percentage of gay people who behave badly will. Just like the small percentage of straight people who behave badly will. And they should both be punished when they break the rules. 

Noel --- 16 years ago -

Also. If people in this country aren't ready for its citizens to have freedom, then people in this country aren't ready to have a military that FIGHTS for freedom. 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 16 years ago -

Also. If people in this country aren't ready for its citizens to have freedom, then people in this country aren't ready to have a military that FIGHTS for freedom.  CLAP Pictures, Images and Photos 

Bishany --- 16 years ago -

Also. If people in this country aren't ready for its citizens to have freedom, then people in this country aren't ready to have a military that FIGHTS for freedom If you are going to say that.. Poll all the military members and let them decide then. They are the ones who will be directly affected and they are the one's who are fighting for the freedom for gays to serve. See what they have to say. Then if they do that... I could care less because that is what the majority wants/believes in. 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 16 years ago -

Im leaving this before I waste to much time, I've learned to make my point clear and walk away cause no matter how much you voice your "own" opinions doesnt mean the other will change theirs, so no point in arguing! BYEEEEE to this post! 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground