Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Health Care - Why the uproar?

who's talking here?

GINA 1
Vanishing Act 1
Little Miss Knowitall 1
Muse 5
Dusk2Dawn 1
IED 8
Crystal 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

IED --- 17 years ago -

Here is what I don't understand about health care. Now, tell me if I have it wrong.. As it stands right now, you have health coverage. You pay into your HMO, PPO, or what have you, every month, and they cover you just in case you are sick or hospitalized. Your insurance company screens people via elimination [waiting] period, to make sure that there are no costly preexisting conditions that may be a liability, and drain funds from the start. What happens to that under the Obama plan? Everyone with problems is now covered, set to leech just like with the other programs in America? At the moment let's say you pay $350 per month for health care for your family. There are no pre-existing conditions. You have a $500 deductible and 80/20 rate, and a $10,000 ceiling. You've had insurance for 3 years now, paid into the system for awhile, and you get sick. REALLY sick. We're talking about a million dollar hospital bill. You have paid the deductible, paid your 20% up to the coverage ceiling [after which, they pay for everything]. Basically, the insurance company is paying [if my math serves me correctly] $997,600. 10,000 ceiling -500 deductible ------ 9,500x0.20 [your percent] = 1900 That is $2400 total [your $500 deductible plus the $1900 that is your 20% up to the coverage ceiling] The insurance company pays the rest, or $997,600 Are you with me so far? Alright, well you get better, you pay your share, and the insurance company pays the rest. Two years later, you are injured again. The bill is even higher, but with that coverage, you are still only paying a tiny fraction of what the insurance company is absorbing. This money is in a "pool" of sorts; other people who have the same company/policy pay into this and it helps cover everyone putting into the pool. Many families go decades paying into the pool and never have to use their coverage. This is who is basically funding the people who are chronically sick. You have 95% of the people paying, just in case the chance that they get sick or hurt, for 5% of the others [sound familiar, in a reverse sort of way?]. So, aside from making everyone buy/carry medical insurance, is the Obama administration also insisting that the insurance companies MUST cover EVERYONE?! If so, will the people in good health have to pay for the very small percentage of leeches who are in terrible health? Why is some obese smoker getting a blood transfusion, kidney, and lung transplant from me? What about people who just lost the genetic lottery, who have chronic diseases that they will suffer with and need expensive treatment for, all of their lives? If I live to 90 and from the time I am 18, pay into the Obama healthcare system, and rarely have anything medically wrong with me, isn't this a form of taxing me a higher percentage for being rich [health-wise]? Taking money that I will never see back because someone who is poor [health-wise] needs it more than I do? Doesn't this sound like the same old BS? How about people who eat terrible food and never exercise? What about those who are obese, who smoke, who do drugs and drink themselves silly for decades? These people take years off their own lives and -MAKE- themselves into a liability for the insurance companies and, by proxy, us. Are they saying that under these new health care provisions, that insurance companies must cover these people, no matter the risk? Won't this bankrupt the insurance companies or dramatically raise rates for EVERYONE? Doesn't this sound a little bit too much like the tax system? Call me heartless. Call me bloodthirsty. How can the rights of the few override the rights of the many? If life is an inalienable right [it is], is it considered a crime to let natural selection run its course and kill these people instead of allowing other people to be drained to prolong the inevitable? There are so many questions I have, and pardon my cynicism, but they are all questions of WHY all of this new health care legislation just sounds absolutely evil! Under this new system, I can see some people being left to die, or being "put to sleep" if they are too old or in poor health. Logan's Run, anyone? So please, after reading this, can you contribute any other information? Does anyone else see eye-to-eye with me here? Am I paranoid or just crazy in my assessment of this mess? 

Dusk2Dawn --- 17 years ago -

You're not paranoid. Sounds similar to other insurance to me as well. I had to change my homeowner's insurance because suddenly it went from $1300 to $2600 a year. When I called and asked about the drastic change in rate I was told it was because of past claims and storms that weren't that bad for that year. So I pay for other's claims, like perhaps the people that keep houses on the beach. I of course quickly changed to another carrier. Car insurance, I've had the same carrier for my car insurance since 1984. My wife had an accident about 2 years ago and totaled a brand new car that we had less than 6 months, my premium has rose about $60 per month. It's insurance and regardless they're attitude is that they won't lose any money. Medical: I'm retired military so I'm very thankful that I don't have those type of premiums just like a number of people in this forum. However, I have two grown daughters in they're twenties that don't, may I add employed. I personally think they are deserving to some type of health care. Preventive health is a factor. Look at how obese some of our children are today. Back in the day when I was a kid P.E. was a class I couldn't wait to get to. Today a lot of schools don't even allow kids to have recess and don't participate in P.E.. They sit in front of their Xbox with fattening foods playing all day. These seditary lifestyles catch up to you over time and into the healthcare system you go. Come on, Type II diabetics amongst teenagers. That's a lifetimes of health issues and they're not even adults yet. So with preventive health care I do agree with President Obama. Would you like your mother to be able to get that mammogram at a younger age and catch the spot before it gets worse? That example in the healthcare care system that study can prevent higher cost down the road for us all of course for anyone's mother. Just some of my thoughts. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 17 years ago -

Just another thought... What about a child who is born with a congenital defect that is corrected, and hasn't had any residual effects of the defect since surgery? Should the insurance company consider it a pre-existing condition? 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

If so, will the people in good health have to pay for the very small percentage of leeches who are in terrible health? Why is some obese smoker getting a blood transfusion, kidney, and lung transplant from me? What about people who just lost the genetic lottery, who have chronic diseases that they will suffer with and need expensive treatment for, all of their lives My son is one of those "leeches" as you said. He's one that "lost the genetic lottery" and to me it's disrespectful and RUDE to even use those terms in relation to people who are sick. I don't agree with the Obamacare anymore than you do but let's not be heartless when we're trying to appear educated. It's kind of an oxymoron. 

IED --- 17 years ago -

I don't agree with the Obamacare anymore than you do but let's not be heartless when we're trying to appear educated. It's kind of an oxymoron. I apologize if I offended you, but there is a hole in what you said. Just because an educated person has a cold heart does not make them uneducated. That is an ad hominem attack. I know that you love your son. I have a niece that has tuberous sclerosis, but I won't deny that she's in "that category". Leech was a harsh word, but it is a fact that this small percent of people drain a high percentage of the money pumped into the system. What happens when all of America is forced to foot the bill for all of America's medical woes, and the insurance companies go bankrupt? Another bailout? 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

I pay for my health insurance now. I pay the same that every other military family pays. When we get out, I'll be paying whatever everone else is paying. Don't tell me that you're paying for my son's medical care- *I* am the one paying for the deductibles and copays. I pay in to my insurance and my family will get the healthcare we paid for. Your words are offensive and hearltess. I pray that you never have to go through what these so called "leeches" and "genetic lottery losers" have to go through. I pray you never have to be the parent to a kid dying of cancer. That you never know what it's like to watch your kid get poked, prodded, hurt. Of all the things you've ever said, this conversation is what I will remember. 

IED --- 17 years ago -

Just an addendum - I'm not trying to attack people or get emotions running high. I know that this topic is VERY sore for some people, because it involves separating your heart from your brain a little bit. It's not easy for most people to look at things without using their feelings to skew things a bit. I don't want this to get too out of hand or get locked, because the issue of health care is a major one - possibly one of the top 3 most important issues of the decade [and maybe the coming decade]. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

It doesn't matter if you're TRYING to attack people. You ARE attacking people by using the UNECESSARY words you chose to use. 

IED --- 17 years ago -

It doesn't matter if you're TRYING to attack people. You ARE attacking people by using the UNECESSARY words you chose to use. They are just words, and your heart is bigger than mine. I really didn't mean to hurt anyone's feelings. Sometimes I feel so alien. 

IED --- 17 years ago -

Alright, so it is obvious that my opinion and wording about some things will differ GREATLY from others here. What else is new? MN, I did not mean to single you or one of your children out - that was NOT my intent. It is obvious that there are some things that I will disagree with EVERYONE on this board about. Can we agree to disagree and move on? If you skip the parts that offend you, does what I posted in the original post make sense? 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

I already told you that I don't support Obamacare. It's not an "agree to disagree" situation. It's the fact that you think it's okay to call sick people those names. It's not okay. Whether they're kids, elderly, etc. Calling them those names shows your lack of respect for them and that is irritating to me. I don't expect everyone to agree with everything but like I said, you find it necessary to give your opinion while name calling and there are other ways to get your point across. 

IED --- 17 years ago -

you find it necessary to give your opinion while name calling and there are other ways to get your point across ..and I said that leech was a harsh word, and that I didn't mean to hurt your feelings. I apologize if I offended you I really didn't mean to hurt anyone's feelings. MN, I did not mean to single you or one of your children out - that was NOT my intent. How many times do I have to apologize? To be honest, I can't think of many people I have shown this much remorse in all my life. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

And what I'm saying is, it doesn't really matter to me that you apologized. Honestly. You never apologized for using the words, only that I got upset. I guess it's my fault that I expect people to have common courtesy and a little empathy for others. We can move on now. It's not getting us anywhere. 

IED --- 17 years ago -

I want one thing to be clear before I move on. This was not a personal attack, MN. That being said, I think that insurance companies have a very tough job. They have to determine what is in the best interest of their customers in order to keep prices manageable for their client base. THAT is what is tough for Americans and Congress to grasp. The insurance company doesn't look at this with a warm heart. If they did, everyone would have coverage, preexisting conditions or not. Is this new legislation going to make it a law that all insurance companies have to cover everyone, and that they cannot charge more than X amount per month or pay period? What will that do to the insurance companies? How will they be reimbursed? Will they be supplemented by tax dollars? Will my taxes go up even though Obama said they won't? 

Crystal --- 17 years ago -

Is this new legislation going to make it a law that all insurance companies have to cover everyone, and that they cannot charge more than X amount per month or pay period? What will that do to the insurance companies? How will they be reimbursed? Will they be supplemented by tax dollars? Will my taxes go up even though Obama said they won't? Because these questions do seem to go unanswered (while our President is busy doing Live appearences on every daytime/nighttime talk show) I am worried about this plan too. It just makes more sense to me that we pay for our own health care by whatever means we have. Now if Obama has a plan for auto insurance or wind and hail, sign me up! (I'm probably waaaay biased over here.. as I have no serious health issues, and I have been a military dependent my entire life) 

GINA --- 17 years ago -

My son is one of those "leeches" as you said. He's one that "lost the genetic lottery" and to me it's disrespectful and RUDE to even use those terms in relation to people who are sick. yep my son is one of those too.. he has a chronic disorder that he will have the rest of his life and i honestly dont care for obama or his damn health plan.. i think it blows... 

Vanishing Act --- 17 years ago -

the purpose of insurance is to protect you in case you need them... just because someone else uses that money doesnt make you any less covered... you choose to have just in case coverage.. if you dont like it.. dont be insured... I dont agree with obama care but I also most definately dont agree with you.. my cousin had cancer at a very young age.. it was covered until my uncles employer switched insurance companies.. so then it became a problem.. the new company wouldnt insure him which is bs.. he didnt ask for cancer.. my family went bankrupt because of it.. nithig they did wrong to deserve that 

IED --- 17 years ago -

If you have a history of using your benefits, your coverage amounts can eventually change, as can your deductible and other limits. Along with high usage, the rates of other people who are on your same plan can go up. As for the scenario of your uncle's employer, I blame it on them and not the insurance company. The insurance company has rules. Their elimination period and preexisting policies are in place to help keep cost down for the clients. The employer didn't HAVE TO switch insurance companies, unless that company went out of business -for some reason-. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground