Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Discipline

who's talking here?

Little Miss Knowitall 12
Allen 1
MrsSmitty10 2
Ja Ja Jacky 6
Dontchawish 1
BOOM BOOM BOOM 15
Kara 1
Boobsy McNicehiney 9
MusicNote 6
Funnies 7
Tarheelover 11
Hdm76 1
Maleficent 6
Jungle Julia 2
DoUntoOthers 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

MrsSmitty10 --- 13 years ago -

At what age did you start disciplining your children and what techniques did you use? 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 13 years ago -

About 8 months when oldest started walking and tried to touch my pretties.

I told him no every time he went near and he left them alone.

I never put up my good stuff and "childproofed". 

MusicNote (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

For a toddler under 1, the idea of "spanking" is really scary BUT I read an expert that said if you're going to "pop" your kid, THIS is the imperative time as you won't hurt them (if done lightly) and they'll catch on quickly. My kids get the typical time out and occassionally they get hands smacked depending on the crime. They also lose privileges quite a bit. 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

I agree with MN. A good hand smacking. And NO! Of course all on their eye level. And tell them what they are doing wrong...and why. Why is very important. Not, "cause I said so" 

Kara --- 13 years ago -

1-2-3 Magic 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

Kara popped some EX. She is having a random moment. One she gets every 273 days or so. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 13 years ago -

And tell them what they are doing wrong...and why. Why is very important

Why does a parent have to explain every time they are doing wrong?

What's wrong with a parent saying "because I said so".

If they're going for the stove, instead of saying "no", say "hot".

If they bite, say "ow". It's not rocket science.

My BIL does the explanation thing. Drives me totally insane!

After about 30 seconds, the kid's eyes are glazing over and they've tuned you out. 

Funnies --- 13 years ago -

I started disciplining my first daughter as early as I can remember.

"No" was the first words of discipline. Stern at that. It worked.

My second daughter is almost 7 months old and "No" is coming into play right now and oddly enough, she smiles when I get all parent-y stern serious with her.

Gah.

Total opposites.

I'm not opposed to a good spanking, but we haven't needed to, yet, and our oldest is 5. She received a diaper swat once when she was about 2.

Time outs work great for us. She stays in time out for 5 minutes. 1 minute for each year alive. After time out, it's a verbal reflection time. If she has nothing to say about why she went in there and what she can do to prevent it next time, it's back to time out for another 5 minutes. Time out is in a specific area of our home as well.


I am also not opposed to saying "because I said so". I don't do it very often, but when I do, I say "because I am the parent and you are the child - end of story".

Children need to know their place at times. 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

How are they going to learn anything if you say that? This is why I feel my daughter has more common sense than most her age! 

Jungle Julia --- 13 years ago -

Never allow your child to manipulate you in ways that may seem minor but have implications down the road:

Example: Kid is screaming because you will not buy him a toy at wal mart and you really need to pick up a few items because you won't have time to come back out later. Do NOT leave the store because you are embarrassed by your child's behavior. This is manipulation at its best. Take the child into the restroom to calm him down.....maybe a pop on the butt if that's how you choose to discipline, etc. The child needs to know that his parent has things to do and he is expected to behave.......do not allow him to think that if he acts bad enough because he didn't get his way then mommy or daddy won't get their way either and will be forced to leave the store. Don't become embarrassed; other people in the store need to learn to either be more tolerant or gather their items and leave the area around you. I see this so much and it drives me crazy. Once a child learns that they can manipulate you in small ways like this, it becomes harder and harder to discipline effectively.

Obviously use common sense.....don't take a child who is ill or irritable into the store, don't take your child shopping for a long time and expect him/her to behave perfectly, etc..... 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 13 years ago -

Do NOT leave the store because you are embarrassed by your child's behavior

No, leave the store because your child is being a bother to other customers AND employees.

You have no idea how far the sound of a temper tantrum carries through the store.

If a child can't act right in public places, let them know you're not taking them ANYWHERE until they can, including places they LIKE to go - no park, no acquarium, etc. 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

No crap! This deturs people from wanting kids. Lord knows if my birth control didn't fail me I wouldn't have any kids rights now (except this one) bc of stupid parents like that! 

Funnies --- 13 years ago -

Kid is screaming because you will not buy him a toy at wal mart


This goes WAY beyond a trip to the store. This all starts at HOME, in my opinion.

If that is happening, then there are serious issues at HOME that need to be CORRECTED.


I can only speak of my very own, but neither one would act like that in a store. PERIOD.

And IF, for some crazy reason (such as, they saw someone at school do it and thought they'd try it) and decided to pull a crazy stunt like this at home or in public - they would LEARN INSTANTLY that THAT BEHAVIOR will NOT BE TOLERATED. END OF STORY.



Do NOT leave the store because you are embarrassed by your child's behavior.


Furthermore, IF said case scenario played out, my children and I would leave INSTANTLY and once outside of the store, LIFE LESSONS would begin.




other people in the store need to learn to either be more tolerant or gather their items and leave the area around you.


Um. Brrrrrnt. Wrong. Negative on this one too. That is just ridiculous in my opinion. If YOU can't act civilized in public, then YOU need to leave the area. NOT the OTHER WAY AROUND. 

Funnies --- 13 years ago -

Jungle Julia is probably one of those mothers in a store that I want to smack the crap out of.

Good golly, what is this world coming to? 

Allen --- 13 years ago -

The wife's psychology book said don't punish first 4 years, while personality is being formed. I'm lucky, my two were very good nearly 100% of the time. 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

Yea dumb teacher reading from a democratic book. First four years the brain is so called "the smartest" during that time. That's when they learn the art of manipulation! Hello!!! Parents!

To clarify...I never said "cause I said so" when or after I disciplined my child. Mainly bc they are learning a lesson and need to know what they did WRONG. Now I've said it plenty of times when I gave a chore or setting my child up not to be annoying during debates and what not. There is nothing worse in my mind than a spanking and not telling your child why and have them reflect on their behavior afterwards. 

Jungle Julia --- 13 years ago -

Good golly, what is this world coming to?


A child acting up in public?!!! Oh the horror.....what is happening to civilization?!!! Children must be perfect in public 100% of the time and it's ok for adults to want to smack the crap out of other adults because they never learned something called tolerance. Awesome. I'll bet your parents didn't allow you to get away with tantrums as a child.....is that why you have tantrums as an adult in wal mart when little toddlers scream? To be quite honest none of my kids have ever had a tantrum over a toy in the middle of the store, but when I see other kids do this I feel empathy because I have enough common sense to realize that very young children cannot be rationalized with. I guess some other people just want to act like a bish because it makes them feel self righteous or something. ;) 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 13 years ago -

People shouldn't have to tolerate other people's misbehaving children.

I see many parents ALLOW their children to carry on. They simply ignore the behavior, instead of addressing the source/reason for the misbehavior.

Those parents have no consideration for others, whatsoever.

While other shoppers can leave the area(they shouldn't have to be inconvenienced, it's not their kid or their fault a parent can't control their child), what about the workers who have to listen to the hysteria? Is it fair to them to have to listen to the theatrics of a petulant child? 

Funnies --- 13 years ago -

Children must be perfect in public 100% of the time

Not ONCE did I say they had to be perfect. Here, let me help you:



Kid is screaming because you will not buy him a toy



There's a difference. If you can't see it, well, then there's just.no.hope.



it's ok for adults to want to smack the crap out of other adults because they never learned something called tolerance.

Deep inside my mind, my mental capacity doesn't tolerate adults allowing their children to continuously act like a damn fool in public.


I'll bet your parents didn't allow you to get away with tantrums as a child....

Yep, you got that right. Never in public was this allowed and if I ever decided to get a hairy turd-ball up my butt and throw one at home; I learned quickly, that this behavior would not be tolerated. And because I learned these things at HOME, there was NEVER an incident out in public.


is that why you have tantrums as an adult in wal mart when little toddlers scream?

Wanting to smack some parental sense into another mother and actually doing it are two different things.



when I see other kids do this I feel empathy because I have enough common sense to realize that very young children cannot be rationalized with.


This has nothing to do with common sense. Heck, common sense tells you to not act like a buffoon in public and to not allow your children to do the same.

Yes, at times, children can not be rationalized with but it is the way you handle these times that determines how they will act and react the next time.

So if a child is screaming because you will not buy him a toy - there are obviously some unresolved issues at HOME which most likely reflects on the PARENTS.

I feel empathy a wee little bit for the screaming child, because it's obvious he/she needs decent parenting in that department. Children WANT boundaries. 

Funnies --- 13 years ago -

I'm finished with you. I see this going in a direction I'd rather just ignore.

Moving along. 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

Last word Lindsay! 

MrsSmitty10 --- 13 years ago -

Yikes!

My daughter is 16 months old. She understands no as we also started that early. But now that she throws tantrums ( out of frustration) we are needing other outlets besides just no. It's only at home, never in public. We also read the one minute time out per year of life general guideline but by the time she calms down it's 20 minutes gone. Someone is with her so she's not screaming because she is alone (she gets afraid easily when alone).

We refuse to spank her. What other forms of discipline would u recommend or have tried for a young toddler other then time out? 

Tarheelover --- 13 years ago -

In my home we use natural and logical consequences for older ones,gentle discipline for babies and toddlers. time outs,taking away toys,computer,tv,gaming devices,cell phones,computer,we ground,etc we do not believe in spanking.
This is a good start for those with small ones.
http://www.askdrsears.com/topics/discipline-behavior/8-tools-toddler-discipline 

Tarheelover --- 13 years ago -

When I see a child "acting up" in public I think to myself "I wonder if that child is special needs?" "Poor Parent" "been there done that got the t-shirt". 

DoUntoOthers --- 13 years ago -

No, leave the store because your child is being a bother to other customers AND employees.

You have no idea how far the sound of a temper tantrum carries through the store.


X2...I am appalled that anyone would suggest staying at the store with a screaming child. Why should my shopping experience be ruined by YOUR child? Especially crying babies. Feed your dang child or comfort him, don't let it sit in their car seat while you look at purses.

This goes WAY beyond a trip to the store. This all starts at HOME, in my opinion

I agree but for different reasons. If I know we are headed to the store there are several things I make sure to do first:

1. My child has had enough sleep and is not tired.
2. My child has had enough to eat and is not hungry.
3. If I cannot or will not buy a small item while in the store (cheap toy or candy), then I will let my child know that this time is not possible, but with good behaviour next time they will get something. I mean really what is the big deal.
4. My child knows that if they do misbehave, (with warnings), they will be taken out of the store and spanked in the car.

If you cannot act appropriately then STAY HOME with Daddy. 

DoUntoOthers --- 13 years ago -

And to answer the orginal question: Children should be disciplined starting very young. But there are different levels/steps.

A firm NO with redirection
A warning with time out
Two warnings with a spanking
Two warnings with a privelege or fav thing taken away. 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

Id never leave a store because my kid was throwing a fit. Then they win. Its grocery shopping not a day at the spa. But I dont generally care what others think.

Positive reinforcement and negative punishment have been proven over and over and over again to be the best method of behavior modification. These can be started early. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 13 years ago -

Id never leave a store because my kid was throwing a fit. Then they win. Its grocery shopping not a day at the spa

They only win if they didn't want to go shopping in the first place.

Like I said earlier, if they misbehave while doing something that has to get done, then they don't get to go ANYWHERE fun, until they can act accordingly. 

BOOM BOOM BOOM --- 13 years ago -

The bribery tactic always worked for me.

"Good girls get what they want, bad girls don't"

Taking something away from them before they have gotten it hurts more than taking away something they already have. Period! 

Boobsy McNicehiney --- 13 years ago -

I'm big on bribery and scare tactics. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground