Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Pleadge of Allegiance = Holocaust??

who's talking here?

Noel 11
Shannon 1
LelaBelle 1
champatlife 3
IED 4
Nikita 1
ihateshoes 1
Ja Ja Jacky 9
proud2Busmc 2
SomethinElse 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

proud2Busmc --- 15 years ago -

This was going around on FB last night and one of my cousins posted it...here is the conversation that followed:

Remember all through grade school saying this every morning to start the day... I pledge allegiance to the flag of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, and to the REPUBLIC for which it stands, one nation under GOD, indivisible, with LIBERTY and JUSTICE for all !!! We no longer do that for... fear... of OFFENDING SOMEONE !!! Let's see how many AMERICANS will re-post this & NOT CARE about offending anyone...Let's go


Girl ITS A MILD FORM OF PROPAGANDA...I NEVER STOOD TO "PLEDGE MY ALLEGANCE" TO A FLAG! NOR WILL I HAVE MY CHILD UNTILL HE UNDERSTANDS JUST WHAT IT MEANS TO PLEDGE HIS ALLEGIANCE..N TO A DAMN OBJECT OF ALL!

cousin When you reach the age in which you grasp the concept of possibly being offend by the pledge teachers or schools don't force you the say it. But whoever you are and whatever your views, at least stand up and respect the flag. hey this count...ry ain't perfect hell no country is and there are countries in much worse condition than ours. Our flag symbolizes many great things that this country values This values and our freedoms should never been taken for granted and ppl should show respect the flag, what it stands for and all those who have sacrificed for our freedom.See More

Girl I WAS ABOUT TO JOIN TO FIGHT "FOR OUR COUNTRY" HA, SO MY SON WOULDNT HAVE TO.. BUT UNTILL THEY UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY ARE BRAINWASHING THEMSELVES W/ IT SHOULD B BANNISHED. NOT TO MENTION THE SEPERATION BETWEEN SCHOOL N GOD! RELIGOUS SCHOOLS R ONE THING..PUBLIC SCHOOL IS A DIFF SUBJUECT. I WAS SET TO FIGHT N DIE FOR MY SONS FREEDOM, NOT SO HE COULD PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO A DAMN FLAG!

person People have died for our right to pledge allegiance to that flag!

girl YEA N I WAS ALMOST ONE OF THEM..N I IN NO WAY AGREE W/ THIS BS PROPAGANDA

girl UNTIL THAT POINT IN TIME SAM..NEITHER MY SON NOR I WILL EVER RECITE THAT CRAP..ONCE RE-WRITEN..POSSIBLY... BUT WHOS TO SAY THAT THE USA IS THE BEST COUNTRY? HAVE U BEEN TO EVERY SINGLE COUNTRY IN THE WORLD?? I DIDNT THINK SO... SO UNTILL THEN I WILL NOT, AND WILL NOT LET MY SON FEED INTO THIS BS.

cousin Fair enough Amanda. As I got older I never said the pledge myself, but I stood for it. I didn't say it in HS because I don't agree with the line "in god we trust" since there should be separation of church and state. However I believe that what our flag symbolizes and what people have sacrificed for all it stands for should be respected

girl WHEN I WAS GOING TO FIGHT N POSSIBLY DIE..I WASN'T DOING IT FOR A FLAG... MY SON WAS THE REASON...DONT TRY N TELL ME THE FLAG REPRESENTS MY SON.. ITS BS..THATS ALL

person Where in the pledge does it say 'we're the best'? It's not saying we're a dominant country, nor is it trying to force religion or anything like that on anyone.. Almost every religion worships a 'God'.. Not like it says one nation, under Jesus Christ our savior..

cousin I didn't say this country is the best. I do believe however that there are other countries that are far worse, whether the reason for that is government, freedom of the people, economic etc

girl I HAD ALREADY ACCEPTED DEATH AND ALL THAT COMES W/ IT.. N SOMETHING WORSE THAN DEATH HAPPENED BEFORE I GOT TO GO... BELIEVE ME..AT ALL TIMES THE FARTHEST THING FROM MY MIND WAS A DAMN FLAG! IF IT MAKES EVERYONE FEEL MORE SECURE..LIKE A SECURITY BLANKET...TAKE A LOOK AT OUR COUNTRY, THE ECONOMY, THE BANKRUPSCY, CORUPTION, CRIME, DEBT, STICKING OUT GIANT NOSE WHERE IT DOESNT BELONG EVEN WHEN WE DONT HAVE THE MEANS TO DO SO...WE'RE LIKE TEENS WHO THINK THEY'RE INVINCIBLE YET ARE FALLING FAST W/ NOBODY TO CATCH. THAT LIL ALLEGIANCE EVERYONE PLEDGED WONT MEAN A DAMN THING TO A SINGLE SAINE SOUL

person No one agrees with everything this country does or represents and if they do, cheers to them. People from our country have also died for THAT right as well.

girl ‎@ JENNI..LOOK UP BUDHISM, AGNOSTIC, ATHEISTS, WICCA..N THERE ARE SEVERAL MORE..

girl WHATEVER U GUYS BELIEVE.. IS YOUR OWN BELIEF AND SHOULD NOT BE PUCHED ONTO INNOCENT, IMMPRESSIVE CHILDREN. THE EXACT SAME WAS DONE DURING THE HOLOCAUST.NO DIFF..PUSHING A BELIEF THAT IS COMMON AMONGST CHILDREN..NOONE THEN SAID IT WAS WRONG,,,JUST A COMMON BELIEF N RIGHT TO THEM...

cousin I'll agree, most religions worship an 'higher being' or a least an philosophy. I think religion, like the flag, should be respected. Just because its not your belief doesn't mean it can't or shouldn't be anyone else. Hence although I don't like the line connecting politics/government to religion, I always stood to respect the flag and pledge.

cousin ‎@ Amanda -I wasn't trying to start anything so big by posting this. I am not trying to shun you or saying your wrong, Its a difference in opinion that's all. But if your offended by my opinion so be it. Our difference in opinion doesn't make either of a bad person or less of an American. People should have the choose(kids included) to decide what they wants to do in the terms of the pledge etc. But I for one will at least always stand up for it

person Amanda notice I said almost every religion.

MEWell from someone who had chosen to serve my country, NOT because I believe in EVERYTHING it stands for, and NOT because I think we are the "best" or our government isn't corrupt but because I am an American and whenever ANYWHERE in the WORLD they have a disaster or an uprising we are the first ones to help them. Your offended by sams post? Its her opinion....if you dont agree...THEN DONT POST IT but dont take her whole status up with your negative bs. All children take are lead by their parents veiws and values growing up, positive and negative. And when they are old enough they make thier own decisions regardless. Its not brainwashing, thats the one thing this country AND THAT FLAG stand for. PEOPLE HAVE LOST LIMB AND LIFE DEFENDING THAT FLAG AND WOULD LOVE TO STAND FOR IT BUT ARE NO LONGER ABLE. comparing the pledge of allegiance to the holocaust? are your for real?

p.s. writing in ALL caps doesnt make your BS point any more valid.

ME and by the way, that FLAG is what represents the freedom to run your mouth with this trash

person A little history on the Pledge of Allegiance.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pledge_of_Allegiance

person Just curious why Amanda never joined to fight.

person Wow Sam, You have a few haters on here but don't let it get you down... I believe in saying the pledge and if you are not going to say it, you are damn well going to stand up while the rest of the class says it... You don't like it... other countries don't have to... go there!!!



....and thats where its at right now.....but REALLY? idk I just had to share because she pissed me off and started my morning agitated. 

ihateshoes --- 15 years ago -

okay i didnt even read all of this but paaalleeasse. i LOVE that the CDC does the pledge every morning and they have a flag holders ( the kids get to take turns ) and i know its my daughters favorite helper activity. Its having respect and pride in your country and nobody MAKES you stand, you arent going to jail or being beaten or starved for not standing and doing the pledge. 

Shannon --- 15 years ago -

I've often wondered: Why is it suddenly a bad thing to have pride in your own country? Why are people embarrassed to say that they are from the Untied States? Have we done some things wrong? Sure. We make mistakes. But why is it that if I say I'm proud to be an American, I am derided? Not only by people from other countries, but by my own fellow Americans? Why is it shameful to take pride in your country? I'm an American. I'm proud of it. I'm not going to make excuses for that. 

champatlife --- 15 years ago -

I love 'Merica! 

proud2Busmc --- 15 years ago -

I love 'Merica! lol we say that all the time @ work MERICA!! Shannon...IDK!! Annoys the heck out of me though 

Nikita --- 15 years ago -

i LOVE that the CDC does the pledge every morning and they have a flag holders ( the kids get to take turns ) and i know its my daughters favorite helper activity. Its having respect and pride in your country and nobody MAKES you stand, you arent going to jail or being beaten or starved for not standing and doing the pledge. 


my sons school has the flag holder activity also and Taylor tells me its his favorite because its the most important. I grew up saying it and I want my son to as well. 

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

It made me mad reading it too. I think that it is just as damaging for children to be fed that extremist bs as it is to be 'brainwashed'. I'm glad she didn't serve. She doesn't deserve a uniform. 

SomethinElse --- 15 years ago -

...I found it really difficult to read the stuff "Girl" wrote. She seems to need to pat herself on the back about "not joining." That and the "impressive" comment. Yea, that would be impressionable, lady. Apparently you not only didn't say the pledge in school, you didn't pay attention either.

ANYHOOTERS. I agree with the ladies that have said that saying the Pledge of Allegiance fosters patriotism in the minds of our young citizens, but isn't it also something that a US citizen should know by heart? Repetition helps with that.

I'm at odds with the whole UNDER GOD part not being allowed because, personally, I'm fine with it. It meshes with my beliefs. I must say, it could be awkward for those with other religious beliefs, though. This country was supposed to be for those who wanted the freedom of religion. (Which gives me itchy feelings about the separation of church and state.) Bahaha

OFF TOPIC 

IED --- 15 years ago -

I'm at odds with the whole "under god" part because it wasn't added to the pledge until several decades and revisions to the pledge. It was closest to perfect before the first revision.
Furthermore, it IS exclusionary in that it favors those who have ONE god, and excludes those who have several gods, or no god.

The big question is: Why do you need a pledge at all? 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

I read about half of it.

"Girl's" grasp on the English language may leave much to be desired, but she's right. Freedom is not defined by a piece of fabric, and getting children to pledge allegiance to something they don't understand -is- a form of public brainwashing. This country craves obedient, unquestioning servants, which they build from the ground up, beginning in grade school, with bullsh*t like this. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

The big question is: Why do you need a pledge at all?

Because it's really expressing loyalty and respect for our country.


Now the God part - I struggle with. On one hand, tradition, tradition, tradition. On the other hand, we don't believe in God so my kids sorta start the day out lying. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

Man. I'm TRYING to get through the rest of it, but mmf. Too much dumb to decipher. I can't focus. O.O 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I don't think that teaching your kids to respect and cherish our country is a form of brainwashing. They spend a few seconds a day repeating that paragraph... that is pretty far from a brainwashing technique. I also teach my kids to respect their elders. I spend way more time on that then on our country. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

LOL Maria! That is what I got out of it. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, she's obviously expecting a pat on the back for considering military service, which is retarded.

From what I've been able to get through, though, neither point of view expressed seems to be all that well-informed.

I'm seeing: "Saying the pledge of allegiance is a Nazi scheme!"

Followed by: "Whatever, that flag represents HEROES!!!ZOMG11!!111ONE! 

IED --- 15 years ago -

Because it's really expressing loyalty and respect for our country.

Kids don't know what liberty and justice are. They don't know that they actually have *even less* liberty, by far, because they are not yet adults, but they pledge allegiance to a flag that doesn't even give them what they are promised from birth.


Now the God part - I struggle with. On one hand, tradition, tradition, tradition. On the other hand, we don't believe in God so my kids sorta start the day out lying.

Like I said, that's the "new pledge". "under god" wasn't added until the 1950s, after several (unneeded) revisions. There's no tradition here. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

They spend a few seconds a day repeating that paragraph...

Exactly. Not analyzing, studying, learning or understanding. Just repeating it. Daily. Weekly. Monthly. Until they can spout it off like "Mary Had a Little Lamb," and pay just as much attention to what they're actually saying.

I was 16 before I realized what nursery rhymes were actually about - in most cases, death, disease and misfortune. I don't consider the reciting of the pledge to be any different. That it's brought into the school system at all, to me, is suspect. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

This is a rant. It's directed at no one in particular, but happens to be somewhat on topic.

I've never understood the blind faith people put in in patriotism toward our country to begin with, all the while bashing on its leaders. You hear it all the time. "Oh, unemployment, oh, cuts in public finding, oh, these terrible politicians and their terrible lies." Well. . . They run this sh*t. Right now, they ARE America. We'd like to believe it's "us," the every man, the little people, but if that were the case, what THEY do wouldn't wind up effecting/controlling OUR lives. Our money, our jobs, our military.

They organize, direct and dictate. Most of us seem to understand that they aren't to be trusted, and yet we -don't- agree that maybe, just maybe the federally funded public school system might possibly be feeding "love, honor and respect your country always!" to our youngsters as a way of setting a precedent for their loyalty?

Rant over. =D 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

Most of them learn absolutely nothing from reciting the pledge

My point exactly. Just because SOME people eventually wake up and go, "Hey, wait a minute, this isn't even TRUE," (or, "Hey, wait a minute, Ring Around the Rosie is about a DISEASE," lol) doesn't mean everyone does. Some continue to blindly recite that sh*t thinking there's power in it, reality, safety, all because they've been taught to simply say it, and never analyze or question it. It ain't cool. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Kids don't know what liberty and justice are. They don't know that they actually have *even less* liberty, by far, because they are not yet adults, but they pledge allegiance to a flag that doesn't even give them what they are promised from birth.




They don't know what a lot of things are. But we teach it to them and they get it.

I guess I can sort of get that maybe it SHOULD be something they can understand early on. But I do like the idea of my kids learning early on to be grateful for the country we live in. A daily reminder isn't extreme, so where is the issue? 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I do agree that the wording and what it is supposed to mean, aren't quite in line and definitely, that perhaps it should be something they can understand if they are reciting it at such an early age. 

IED --- 15 years ago -

But I do like the idea of my kids learning early on to be grateful for the country we live in. A daily reminder isn't extreme, so where is the issue?

Just because we're, allegedly, "the greatest country in the world" doesn't mean that we're the best we ever could be; We're not.


"Having a child repeat a daily mantra of allegiance to a system that he/she can’t possibly understand is silly. To have that child swear loyalty to a concept that doesn’t really exist is obscene manipulation. Liberty and justice for all? They want you to pledge allegiance and they can’t even provide the product. Buyer beware.

Liberty means freedom from restriction or government control. Who has less freedom from restriction and government control than a child? Child molesters have more rights. So, kids, next time they want you to say the Pledge of Allegiance, ask for a copy of Hustler. Or the car keys. Or a ballot. Or a gun or a beer or a smoke or a job or at least a passing grade in political science.

The pledge is nothing more than forced advertising and everybody knows it. If this country came through with all the promises that are drilled into you in the school system, you wouldn’t need a pledge. Great things don’t need to tell you how great they are, much less have you repeat it like a cult member until you can’t sandblast it out of your brain. Teach them the basics to get by and encourage free thinking. If you’re really all that hot I bet the kids will figure it out on their own." 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

A daily reminder isn't extreme, so where is the issue?

Not everyone is (or should be) grateful for living in America. In debates like this, I see a lot of people say, "Try living somewhere else if it's so bad!," but A.) Not everyone can afford to leave the country, and B.) it makes as much sense as saying, "Fine, if you're so miserable having HPV, go get AIDS, then!"

We lose more and more of what that pledge boasts about with every year, which I think is a much more valuable lesson than, "Sure, little Johnny, this country may lie, cheat, deceive and manipulate, but just think how bad you'd have it if you'd have been born elsewhere!"

I don't know. The whole thing just makes me uncomfortable. Because this:

They don't know what a lot of things are. But we teach it to them and they get it.

isn't what happens when a kid recites the pledge. That's what I've been saying. We DON'T teach them respect by having them say those words, we don't -teach- them anything. We have them repeat something and accept it at face value. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -


Just because we're, allegedly, "the greatest country in the world" doesn't mean that we're the best we ever could be; We're not.



And no one said we are. We aren't perfect. Never have been, never will be. No one and nothing is though. That doesn't mean we can't be proud of what this country has accomplished.

I don't agree with every single thing our government does/has done. But I realize that there is no way everyone can win. We all have different expectations. If you're given what you want, then I won't be given what I want. I can't fault the government for not being able to please us both at the same time. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

Which isn't to say that a kid should only be taught how much their country sucks, that came out wrong, lol.

I think it should be left alone when they're too young to understand "shades of gray." At some point, everyone needs to learn that brave people fought for this country and lost their lives, but that others just enlisted to pay off college debts, and some deployed and raped civilians in other countries and hurled puppies off of cliffs for entertainment.

At some point, everybody needs to learn that this country was founded on amazing principles, on respect for individual rights and freedoms, that our nation's founders went through hel! to stake this land as ours. But they also need to learn about all the people we destroyed to get there, and that the values we were founded on have been ripped to pieces by the laziness and greed of citizens and politicians alike.

They need to know that some people risk their lives daily in uniforms that don't deploy, that men and women face fires, criminals and thugs to keep our streets clean, but they also need to know that it doesn't mean you can trust a public worker; they are as susceptible to corruption and filth and greed as everyone else, and our own government has been proven for a liar time and again, hiding away its shadiest dealings from citizens who deserve to know what, exactly, they're pledging allegiance to.

It's not suitable material for the age the pledge is taught to, so I say we skip it until they're old enough to understand the reality of it, and then decide for themselves if they want that to be a part of their day. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

isn't what happens when a kid recites the pledge. That's what I've been saying. We DON'T teach them respect by having them say those words, we don't -teach- them anything. We have them repeat something and accept it at face value.



But that is the POINT of it. Regardless of what you get out of it. That was the point. And as I noted up there, I agree completely that what it is supposed to be, and what it is, are not in line. I also thought about it and agreed that what they have to recite should be edited so that these kids can understand it. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -


But that is the POINT of it. Regardless of what you get out of it.


I think that's where we disagree, unless you mean that's the point of the pledge itself, rather than 'that's the point of having kids recite it.' I firmly believe having children recite the pledge is just another way for our public education system to create obedient, respectful little servants. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I think that's where we disagree, unless you mean that's the point of the pledge itself, rather than 'that's the point of having kids recite it.



Yes ma'am, the point of the pledge.


eta: The point is supposed to be to show your respect for our country. I agree with that idea. But I don't agree with the other things tossed in there. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

This entire conversation was basically a cleaner, more intelligent, more mature re-make of what happened on that girl's FB last night. XD

I feel like we should send them the link and say, "This is how it's done." 

champatlife --- 15 years ago -

too many paragraphs to start the morning . So, I stopped reading. I think 3rd grade is when we discussed the meaning of the pledge of allegiance and the American flag in simplicity. Every couple yrs it was in our history lesson and built on in more depth. Maybe my teachers loved 'Merica just as much as me.

WAWAWA! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground