Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Breed Restrictions

who's talking here?

~*MarLa Singer*~ 2
Vanishing Act 1
**Kathy with a K** 8
Muse 14
LelaBelle 1
champatlife 4
Karnagia-a 3
countrygrl 3
Happy 3
JessJ 3
FlamingoLuver1 19
Bernadette 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Muse --- 16 years ago -

As of June 15, 2010 all pit, doberman and wolf hybrid breeds are banned from Lincoln Military Housing. Any animal already living in housing has to be registered with the city and then housing in order to be grandfathered in. One strike and you're out rule on all of the restricted breeds As of May 1, 2010, all applicants for residency that own one of the breed bans will be rejected from waiting lists and will not be able to move into housing. 

JessJ --- 16 years ago -

Yeah they had this in Okinawa too..even though it wasn't lincoln military housing! 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Lejeune already has this restriction. 

Vanishing Act --- 16 years ago -

That is great to hear! Sorry again for your loss but am glad that you know your kids will be much safer with this in place! 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

Dobermans? I have one and talked to the vet and housing last week cuz a friend of mine is keeping her while I'm gone and she has day care kids. They told me Dobermans aren't on the list. Great. So when we move we might have to get rid of her? (I[m already considering that cuz she's been beyond naughty lately.) 

FlamingoLuver1 --- 16 years ago -

I know Lincoln that was used for housing in Yuma, Az already has this. But theirs is for pits, wolf hybrids, and rotties and those mixed with them. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Kathy, Dobermans are on the list for my housing. This is all in response to the resident outcry over the handling of Rocco's death. All of those breeds and anything mixed with one of those breeds. 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

So each base has their own aggressive breed list? 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Kathy, MOST bases will have breed restrictions. It depends on the base. The difference is that down there, AMCC runs the base. Up here it's Lincoln. To my knowledge, they are the only two who run housing. 

FlamingoLuver1 --- 16 years ago -

If you live on a Marine base they all have the same restriction is what i was told back in like August at our old base that was ran by Lincoln. Those breeds are Pits, wold Hybrids, and rotties and those mixed with them. It wasnt housings choice it was an actual marine corps order. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I dont live in MC housing. I live on a Navy/Coast Guard base and it all came down from regional today because of the numerous residents contacting regional and even the news about the situation here. 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

Guess we'll figure it all out when we get orders and see what our new station has to say about our dog. He wants to go to Miramar. 

Happy --- 16 years ago -

This is sad. I feel horrible about what happened to your poor dog. It never should have happened. But when will people realize that banning a breed is not going to help? People just need to be more responsible. Its not the dogs its their useless owners. So many wonderful dogs are going to be dumped at overflowing shelters and then euthanized just because their breed is banned. What happens when someone is bit by an over protective Golden or an untrained Yorkie? This is not going to help the situation - just hurt a lot of wonderful pets. Once again MN I am so sorry for your dog and I do think that that PARTICULAR dog needed to be removed but not the whole breed banned. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I didn't push for the breed ban. Actually, I haven't pushed for anything. I dont have to though. Many, MANY residents are all up housing's butt. Those dogs have the propensity to be dangerous if not raised correctly whereas other breeds wouldn't. As for Pits, I'm normally a "punish the deed not the breed" type of person but I can't help but wonder if pits are predisposed to violence much like homosexuals are predisposed to homosexuality. 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

wonder if pits are predisposed to violence much like homosexuals are predisposed to homosexuality. Not exactly an equal comparison but I understand what you mean. Like are Pitts born that way much like a gay person is "born that way". (I don't believe that personally, but that's another topic.) 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Kathy, LOL!! That's precisely why I used that particular example. No one knows if people are born gay and no one can say that pits aren't born violent. I dont honestly know how I feel. I've met pits who were great dogs but I never felt comfortable (probably because of the hype) and I've met other dogs that were aggressive and not pits. 

Happy --- 16 years ago -

Those dogs have the propensity to be dangerous if not raised correctly whereas other breeds wouldn't. Ummm.. I am sorry but ALL dogs have the "propensity to be dangerous" it's natural dog behavior - which is why socialization and training are essential in all dogs; from tiny lap dogs to huge working dogs. Pits are actually quite the opposite of these horrible stereotypes and actual unbiased studies and tests have shown that pit bulls are actually less aggressive then many of peoples favorite "family-friendly" breeds. I pride myself on the fact that I do not give into stereotypes of people, places or dogs. As history has often shown stereotypes are false and allowing communities to be fueled by them is a major mistake. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Pits are actually quite the opposite of these horrible stereotypes and actual unbiased studies and tests have shown that pit bulls are actually less aggressive then many of peoples favorite "family-friendly" breeds. I can find "proof" of just about ANY opinion I want to have. MY opinion is that they PROBABLY ARE more dangerous than other breeds based on the number of attacks/deaths. Again, that's JMO. I'm not calling YOU ignorant so please refrain from assuming that I am. 

countrygrl --- 16 years ago -

And with the breed restrictions, your "grandfathering in" does not transfer base to base. So if you have a dog on the list and its the same as your next station, you cannot take the dog 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

And with the breed restrictions, your "grandfathering in" does not transfer base to base. That sucks. 

countrygrl --- 16 years ago -

yes it does. A friend of mine just went through this 

Happy --- 16 years ago -

I'm not calling YOU ignorant so please refrain from assuming that I am. I am sorry, I was under the impression that this was an open forum. I never assumed you were ignorant, nor implied it. I simply quoted your words because they are typical of the attitude that has come about because of bad owners and people that refuse to look past a dogs breed. Of course you can find "proof" in any direction. That is why I did my own research and read tons of articles/studies that go both ways as well as have worked with hundreds of animals - and truly I have met aggressive pits but I have met a lot more that wouldn't hurt anyone/thing. I know that I will be bad mouthed because I feel the need to stand up for things that always seem to get the raw end of the deal. But I am fine with that. I have no issues with anyone here - I just hate the number of animals that are needlessly killed because of stupid ineffective breed restrictions. 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

whens the last time you heard of a golden retriever puppy eating a baby's toes? I'm all for punishing the deed and not the breed, but some dogs were bred for agressive behavior, and because of that their blood lines are "dirty" and it's near impossible for an average every day owner to insure the bloodline of their dog never came from agressive roots. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

am sorry, I was under the impression that this was an open forum. I never assumed you were ignorant, nor implied it. I simply quoted your words because they are typical of the attitude that has come about because of bad owners and people that refuse to look past a dogs breed. Of course you can find "proof" in any direction. That is why I did my own research and read tons of articles/studies that go both ways as well as have worked with hundreds of animals - and truly I have met aggressive pits but I have met a lot more that wouldn't hurt anyone/thing. I know that I will be bad mouthed because I feel the need to stand up for things that always seem to get the raw end of the deal. But I am fine with that. I have no issues with anyone here - I just hate the number of animals that are needlessly killed because of stupid ineffective breed restrictions. I have done my research as well. Like I stated before, I didnt implement the ban breed- housing did. I'm sorry but they're not ALWAYS wrong. Home insurance companies, property managers, animal control officers- they aren't always right. There is something that predisposes certain breeds to violence. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Also, why do you think that people choose pits when they are training for dogfighting? 

JessJ --- 16 years ago -

Guess we'll figure it all out when we get orders and see what our new station has to say about our dog. He wants to go to Miramar. Well most of the housing at Miramar is DOG FREE! A lot of the housing there doesn't allow pets at all!! Especially the newer ones, (on base at Miramar, Serra Mesa, NTC, etc) Those don't even allow dogs There are only a couple that allow them, and those houses wouldn't be my top pick by any means..and they are no where near miramar!!! FYI 

JessJ --- 16 years ago -

I have done my research as well. Like I stated before, I didnt implement the ban breed- housing did. I'm sorry but they're not ALWAYS wrong. Home insurance companies, property managers, animal control officers- they aren't always right. There is something that predisposes certain breeds to violence. that's very true! My mother owns several houses, and she said her homeowners insurance won't allow her to have pits at any of the houses. 

FlamingoLuver1 --- 16 years ago -

whens the last time you heard of a golden retriever puppy eating a baby's toes? Just want to say that growing up we had a golden retriever that bit the neighboors little girl that we were friends with for no reason. so it can happen with any dog. To this day i will never leave a child alone with a dog not even my own dogs. 

FlamingoLuver1 --- 16 years ago -

Guess we'll figure it all out when we get orders and see what our new station has to say about our dog. He wants to go to Miramar. If your dog is any of the breeds that is listed on the Marine Corps breed ban they will not let you have your dog in housing, not even to visit. Its the same at all Marine Corps bases. 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

Just want to say that growing up we had a golden retriever that bit the neighboors little girl that we were friends with for no reason. so it can happen with any dog. To this day i will never leave a child alone with a dog not even my own dogs. for no reason, were adults there watching? Many breeds have not friendly dogs, but actually chewing a babies toes off? (i believe the baby was 3 months old and they had to amputate one of her feet) I agree don't leave children unattended with an animal... I'm scared of chow chows because my brother was attacked by one as a child, and I'm sure they're not notorious for being vicious. My point is certain breeds were bred for their aggressive traits, and for many it has come as an instinct to them. Training helps in most situations, but certain dogs that have been beloved well trained family pets have turned on their owners. Certain breeds it is more common. The breed restrictions didn't purely come about for no reason. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground