Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

I need some advice..

who's talking here?

Vicky 3
☆Mashley1219☆ 1
~~J~~ 6
**Kathy with a K** 7
Little Miss Knowitall 4
Making my MARK♥ 17
Jacky 1
Jamie 1
*AmbieBambie* 1
champatlife 2
*Loralee* 2
Karnagia-a 1
Doctor of Veterinary Medicine 7
OhIoLaDy 1
Jewel 31

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

Here's the situation: L is not my husband's daughter (for those that don't know)but her father doesn't pay child support or see her very often at all. He seen her at court in the summer but other than that few hours, it's been almost two years. When we went to court, he asked to claim her on taxes this year and I agreed for this year and this year only. None of which is in writing. All our court papers are null and void except for the newest ones. (Just some insight: When she was younger he did it a few years in a row without my permission and I had to prove that she lived with me, ect. They made him pay back like 10,000 dollars) Anyway, my mom says to claim her and tell him to eff off. She lives here, my husband supports her, and he doesn't pay child support. Not only that, but he doesn't call her or send her ANYTHING for birthdays or holidays. He doesn't even call every few weeks. I'm torn between what to do. I know that legally I can claim her and he would be in trouble, not me. (Been through it before) The problem is that I'm such a nice freakin' person and I feel like crap doing it. He only wants his daughter as tax purposes, yet I feel like crap for him getting screwed. What do you guys think? 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

Seriously... 

Jamie --- 16 years ago -

Why would you let him claim her? I wouldn't allow it in a million years if he didn't help out. I would do your taxes with her and without her and see the difference she will make in your refund. Maybe that will help your decision. I would also tell him you were going to claim her if you decide to. He doesn't have a leg to stand on, it is your choice. 

~~J~~ --- 16 years ago -

Looks pretty cut and dry to me. What does being nice have to do with it? She's your child and lives with you. You and your husband provide the support for her. If your ex provides nothing, why should he get something. Ask yourself this, the $ that he would get back for claiming her, would he give it to you to help support your daughter? 

Karnagia-a --- 16 years ago -

Okay Julie...he's using his daughter for money. He doesn't help, and he seems like he's NO form of a father. I can understand the torn feeling you have but he does NOT deserve to reap rewards or benefits from a child he wants nothing to do with. You KNOW what the smart answer to this situation is, girl. 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

The problem is that I'm such a nice freakin' person and I feel like crap doing it. He only wants his daughter as tax purposes, yet I feel like crap for him getting screwed. WHy would he get screwed? Sounds like he's been screwing you. Stop being so nice! L lived with you, was supported by you and M. Doesn't sound like her bio-dad has done much for her. I'd get it in writing that you guys claim her and he doesn't. 

Making my MARK♥ --- 16 years ago -

Jewel- I have the same issue but ours is in writing. He gets to claim our oldest. But only as dependant.(SP?) I am allowed to claim her as EIC and you are as well. You provide support for her 24/7.I went back 4 yrs,and interest tacks on.Over $6000 my ex owes for EIC he was not entitled to. So if you dont have it in writing the IRS will consider first to file and one she resides with.:) Hope I helped. 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

Why would you let him claim her? I wouldn't allow it in a million years if he didn't help out. I would do your taxes with her and without her and see the difference she will make in your refund. Maybe that will help your decision. I would also tell him you were going to claim her if you decide to. He doesn't have a leg to stand on, it is your choice. I have. There's a 2000 dollar difference. 

☆Mashley1219☆ --- 16 years ago -

i would not let him do that a kid is not just way to get money and if he has not put any foer in, no way would i give him any of that you work hard for that and you need that for your self for her. close ,foood, school supplys, even bills becasue she lives there to she use water lol. 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

Ask yourself this, the $ that he would get back for claiming her, would he give it to you to help support your daughter? That's a big fat negative. 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

He screwed me out of child support (when he did have to pay) for two years. 6500 dollars worth. And the courts in Jersey did NOT make him pay it back. 

Doctor of Veterinary Medicine --- 16 years ago -

I wouldn't let him claim her -- he doesn't support her. I'd call him up & tell him that after some discussion & thought, you've decided that you're going to claim her (since he hasn't contributed). If he's interested in the tax break of having a child, he needs to support that child. I'd let him know before you file, etc. Because otherwise it'll cause a big up roar of him accusing you of lying, etc. 

Making my MARK♥ --- 16 years ago -

Oh btw- it was set up in court 5 yrs ago for me. But he claims oldest and only as dependant0yet he claimed for both getting an extra 1500 or so he was not entitled to. 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

WHy would he get screwed? Because they will make him pay it back like last time. 

~~J~~ --- 16 years ago -

That's a big fat negative. Then there is absolutely no reason for him to claim her. Let it go girl. Take care of your own. He's a grown man and can take care of himself. 

Making my MARK♥ --- 16 years ago -

IT is his duty to pay support whether or not he sees the child or not. I was in the right when I talked to my lawyer he told me there is no way in H_LL I should let him get away with money that was for us not him. Its like he pays support to get a fat check come feb. 

Making my MARK♥ --- 16 years ago -

He would have to take you to court before anything. 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

So if you dont have it in writing the IRS will consider first to file and one she resides with.:) Hope I helped. Well, like I saud, he did it before and I just had to show school records. She went to school here the entire year so that's fina and dandy. I know that I can legally claim her. I just feel like an @ss. I think my biggest problem is that I always had a soft spot for my daughter. I had to FORCE him to be a dad when she was younger. She told him in court she wants my husband to be her dad. We were working on adoption papers. He cried about it and I told him "I forced you for nearly 10 years. Now you want to try and be a dad?" 

~~J~~ --- 16 years ago -

WHy would he get screwed? Because they will make him pay it back like last time. That's only him screwing himself! 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

I'd call him up & tell him that after some discussion & thought, you've decided that you're going to claim her (since he hasn't contributed). If he's interested in the tax break of having a child, he needs to support that child. He is not married but has a fiance. They have a child together and she has one on her own. He can claim one and she can claim the other. I don't see the problem with this. They will make out either way. He just wants to be greedy. 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

WHy would he get screwed? Because they will make him pay it back like last time. Well, if he isn't entitled (morally) to claim her then it would seem he screwed himself. Just for paper-trail purposes, I'd send him a certified letter stating you are claiming her. That way if he claims her too and something gets audited you'll have proof of your intentions. 

Making my MARK♥ --- 16 years ago -

I think my biggest problem is that I always had a soft spot for my daughter. I had to FORCE him to be a dad when she was younger. She told him in court she wants my husband to be her dad. We were working on adoption papers. He cried about it and I told him "I forced you for nearly 10 years. Now you want to try and be a dad?" I done the same- But you need to consider you and your hubby now.Dont be nice to him for any reason.If he wanted his tax money back he would be current. He just better hope the state doesnt take from what he does get for back support . 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

IT is his duty to pay support whether or not he sees the child or not I know. I suspended his child support (wasn't much anyways) for his sake and the right to a passport. 

Making my MARK♥ --- 16 years ago -

Dont feel like an @ss. Smile-:) It will all work itself out. 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

She told him in court she wants my husband to be her dad. We were working on adoption papers. Has that gone thru yet? 

Making my MARK♥ --- 16 years ago -

As Kathy stated send a certified letter informing him of what is going to happen. He has to sign for it and that will be proof you sent it to him and he accepted. 

Making my MARK♥ --- 16 years ago -

Usually the adoption wont go through unless he signs all rights away which means he does not have to pay support or have any right to tax ,child. 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

He just better hope the state doesnt take from what he does get for back support . They aren't making him pay back support. They dropped it and cleared it stating there was no proof that anything was or was not paid. We had it set up where he paid directly to me, which worked out fine till a year or so into it when he lost his job and I was being nice enough to not take him back to court. Finally, I gave up and took him back in. That was when she was 5. 

Doctor of Veterinary Medicine --- 16 years ago -

They will make out either way. He just wants to be greedy. I think you've just answered your own question. :-) ;-) I'm not saying I would call him being a raging witch & all that. But I would call & let him know that you've done some thinking & discussing & you are claiming your daughter. Tell him that you're sorry for going back on what you said, but it's the right thing to do. Yadda yadda. I'm similar -- I feel like crap for going back on what I've said... even if the person I'm going back on is someone who is taking advantage of me. *shrugs* It's hard. But it'll be worth it. 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

Has that gone thru yet? Not yet. After this little thing, he is going to throw a fit. 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground