Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Ethnicity issues......

who's talking here?

Rosela 5
Sakura 2
****KELLS**** 1
lady in the valley 2
Vicky 2
♫ginger♫ 1
val 3
PeggyHill 1
Cynthia Rose 4
Jacky 1
♥Charlene♥ 1
☼♥Brandi♥ 5
Muse 3
sarah with an H 1
LelaBelle 1
Baker's Wife 1
Preggo w. #2 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

☼♥Brandi♥ --- 17 years ago -

So I take my daughter to the doctors...and for those of you who dont know..my baby is half white and half phillipino...I also have two other kids who are totally white so Ive never faced the issue of the question of the mark your ethnicity box....Im looking and im asking myself...Is she asian or is she white or is she pacific islander lol So after contemplating this, I mark white and asian both but this got me to thinking alot about it... So i get home and I ask my husband what do you think mixed people should say they are...He says they are whatever is obvious...Like if you look black your black or if you look white your white..you get it...well I said that doesnt make any sense with white people because Im actually mixed if you consider that im german, english, irish, dutch, and indian all mixed up in one.. so what am I. he says your irish cuz you have red hair and freckles..its whats obvious..I said well others say i look german..And I said how does that make sense when my sister claims shes german and my brother claims hes indian and the other one is irish, so if you hear that you assume we dont have the same mom and dad but we do...He said thats why white people only have one box labeled white to check lol.....Guess that answers that but still if bella starts looking more white which she is as she grows, does she then pick whatever she wants to be...sigh...im confused on this issue.. 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

I'm a mix like you. I usually go with the majority rule. In the 50-50 case, however Bella looks. If she's dark, phillipino. If she is fair, white. That's how i'd do it... but I think you have the right Idea with letting her choose when she get's older. She'll get more scholarships in college if she is a minority so that might be beneficial to her. :D 

lady in the valley --- 17 years ago -

my husband is part white almost 50 % but he says hes spanish because he looks spanish but he is also part black so when he checks boxes he usually checks both spanish and black because he gets benefits for being a minority 

Sakura --- 17 years ago -

My girls are white,black and Native American....ALL their birth certificates state they are black... most hospitals if you ARE married mark the race based on the father unless you specify otherwise or are unmarried then it goes by the race of the mother. Now as my girls get older then the decision is up to them....I normally leave it blank....or select all that applies. 

Sakura --- 17 years ago -

he usually checks both spanish and black because he gets benefits for being a minority sounds like the wrong reason to me.... 

lady in the valley --- 17 years ago -

well he looks mostly spanish and is mostly spanish but the decision is up to him whether you think its right or wrong lots of people check black instead of just white or just spanish because they get benefits . its just a fact 

val --- 17 years ago -

my baby is half white and half phillipino.. guess you answered the Q yourself :) yep, mark both asian and white (not pacific islander) i think the term refers to guam and other micronesian peoples... If she's dark, phillipino not necessarily...filipinos are a mixed race in themselves - depending on their ethnicity too - chinese, spanish, malay, native, etc.. and it's spelled FILIPINO :) i know it's confusing, my hubby always gets that mixed up cause the country is spelled PHILIPPINES after King Philip of Spain .. 

♥Charlene♥ --- 17 years ago -

Julibell --- 17 min ago - quote - flag comment he usually checks both spanish and black because he gets benefits for being a minority sounds like the wrong reason to me.... I would agree with Amber on this one. If it works to benefit you why not? My kids have hawaiian in them, so if they have enough they qualify for more when we are in hawaii.. I know they are mostly white, but the benefits would be best to claim hawaiian.. it's no scam there.. they are what they are.. if he wants to claim for better benefits.. why not? 

Vicky (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

filipino is pacific islander... 

☼♥Brandi♥ --- 17 years ago -

yea thats why i was saying im not sure if shes pacific islander cuz eddie says thats what he marks when asked 

Jacky --- 17 years ago -

I always mark other because I am so tired of the race issue. I mark other for my children too. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

she is pacific islander... or at least if I were her mother that is what I would claim. 

Preggo w. #2 --- 17 years ago -

my hubby marks other. he's part black/white. my son's birth certificate says white (hubby was depolyed when i had him) so it all depends. if this child comes out like my son he will most likely be "considered" white. i'm part native american but i go as "white" 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

So.....write "none of your business" and then draw a box and check it :) 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

Or put "other" and then write next to it that all 3 of your dads are different races so you're really not sure. 

Preggo w. #2 --- 17 years ago -

it all depends on how you feel honestly. like i said my hubby marks other but his brother marks white. but his brother doesn't look like he has a drop of black in him except for his hair (when he lets it grow out) 

☼♥Brandi♥ --- 17 years ago -

Or put "other" and then write next to it that all 3 of your dads are different races so you're really not sure. Haha you crack me up 

****KELLS**** --- 17 years ago -

well he looks mostly spanish and is mostly spanish but the decision is up to him whether you think its right or wrong lots of people check black instead of just white or just spanish because they get benefits . its just a fact this is just funny to me. its a fact? really? 

val --- 17 years ago -

we've (Flipinos )never been referred to as Pacific Islanders.. i know it's confusing cause we are in the pacific and the country is a group of islands.. oh, i noticed in a few forms there is actually a checkmark/box for Filipino..so i checked that LOL hope this clarifies the Pacific Islander term: Pacific Islander (or Pacific Person, pl: Pacific People, also called Oceanic[s]), is a geographic term to describe the Austronesian inhabitants of any of the three major sub-regions of Oceania: Polynesia, Melanesia and Micronesia.[1][2] According to the Encyclopedia Britannica, these three regions, together with their islands consist of: Polynesia: The islands scattered across a triangle covering the east-central region of the Pacific Ocean. The triangle is bounded by the Hawaiian islands in the north, New Zealand in the west, and Easter Island in the east. The rest of Polynesia comprises Samoa (American Samoa and Western Samoa), the Cook Islands, French Polynesia (Tahiti and The Society Islands, Marquesa Islands, Austral Islands, and the Tuamotu Archipelago), Niue Island, Tokelau and Tuvalu, Tonga, Wallis and Futuna, and Pitcairn Island. Melanesia: The island of New Guinea, the Bismarck and Louisiade archipelagos, the Admiralty Islands, and Bougainville Island (which make up the independent state of Papua New Guinea), the Solomon Islands, the Santa Cruz Islands (part of the Solomon Islands), New Caledonia and Loyalty Islands, Vanuatu (formerly New Hebrides), Fiji, Norfolk Island, and various smaller islands. Micronesia: The islands of Kiribati, Guam, Nauru, the Commonwealth of the Northern Marianas, the Republic of the Marshall Islands, Palau, and the Federated States of Micronesia (Yap, Chuuk, Pohnpei, and Kosrate, all in the Caroline Islands). 

Cynthia Rose --- 17 years ago -

I suppose my children will be 'others,' or whatever they choose to identify themselves with. My husband is full Mexican but doesn't strongly identify with the culture. I don't think they should only list the father's race on the birth certificate. That doesn't make sense. 

Rosela --- 17 years ago -

I'm Filipino and always mark Pacific Islander, not Asian. 

Baker's Wife --- 17 years ago -

I'm latina and my husband is white, one daughter looks white and the other looks mexican, i check both. 

☼♥Brandi♥ --- 17 years ago -

I'm Filipino and always mark Pacific Islander, not Asian. Really I thought you might be but I didnt want to ask because I could be wrong and offend you 

Rosela --- 17 years ago -

Really I thought you might be but I didnt want to ask because I could be wrong and offend you =) Its ok, most people think I'm either Korean or something else. The baggers at the commissary talk to me in their language, and I'm like, "HUH?" LOL. But yes, I am =) Hows that book helpin btw? 

Cynthia Rose --- 17 years ago -

The baggers at the commissary talk to me in their language, and I'm like, "HUH?" LOL. LOL! Sorry, that cracked me up! 

Rosela --- 17 years ago -

LOL! Sorry, that cracked me up! LOL Sorry. I have that happen every time they bag for me though. When I say huh, then they say, "Oh you're not..." I say, "No, I'm not..." and just smile :) 

sarah with an H --- 17 years ago -

thats hilarious and cracked me up too!!! i had a lady start talking to me in spanish one time and i looked at her and smiled and turned around. i dont look spanish at all, im white and fair!!! 

PeggyHill --- 17 years ago -

i always have the baggers at the comissary ask me if im filipino or arabian..im like..uhm...no.im a mexican.lol 

Cynthia Rose --- 17 years ago -

thats hilarious and cracked me up too!!! i had a lady start talking to me in spanish one time and i looked at her and smiled and turned around. i dont look spanish at all, im white and fair!!! Whenever I went to El Cerro with my husband (before he deployed), the waiter never spoke to us in English. The one guy who is like, the owner (manager maybe?) started recognizing me and saying simple things to me in Spanish to tease me because I'm just a white girl with a Mexican, LOL. Kinda as if to say, "you know you have to learn Spanish now!" haha 

☼♥Brandi♥ --- 17 years ago -

yea it helps alot thanks 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground